4 ms·
Instead of going into these abstract discussions about arms-races and how everything is inevitable, can someone give me a practical example of where simply not
by Barrin92 6y ago
Instead of going into these abstract discussions about arms-races and how everything is inevitable, can someone give me a practical example of where simply not using autonomous weapons has disastrous implications for national defense?
Because as I see it the primary domains where these weapons seem to excel is drone-warfare, border control, surveillance and so on, not necessarily national defense.
These technologies seem more like a backdoor to eliminate human ethical concerns from decision-making and empower domestic policing (which is where military technology tends to go), rather than defending the country. What's a concrete example where, even when China or Russia do not honor a ban, the US could not simply strike with a human in the loop?
Democratic societies who value human rights already forego the use of countless of military tactics they could potentially employ. It hasn't made any of them defenseless.
- throwaway1777 6y agoDrone warfare and border control ARE national defense. That aside, if China or Russia gets AI robot guns it’s gonna be like boomers playing against kids with aimbot in counter strike. The US will get destroyed.
- fwn 6y agoJust to add one small note here: A drone is, in academic literature on security, not a autonomous weapon or robot. Drones are assumed to be remote controlled, therefore retain a human decision maker at all times. Robots would make such decisions themselves. While drones come with their own set of problems (usual suspects are transparency, deployment regulations, sovereignty, decision making without skin in the game, etc.) they are distinct from the set of problems robots / "autonomous" weapons introduce. (Like distinction, proportionality, transparency & responsibility)
- suby 6y agoI am in agreement with you in regards to the dangers autonomous weapons pose for domestic use, but unfortunately drone-warfare is a national defense issue and already is impacting how wars are fought. https://www.forbes.com/sites/pauliddon/2021/03/25/the-last-azerbaijan-armenia-war-redefined-how-small-nations-fight-modern-battles/?sh=10edff1e7dd3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/pauliddon/2021/03/25/the-last-a...
- Barrin92 6y agoJust to be precise here, I'm not advocating ignoring all modern technologies like drones altogether. The concern here is autonomous weaponry in particular. I'm against taking the human out of the loop and leaving the decision and responsibility to kill to a machine. I can think of many situations where a drone is a necessary technology to win a war but of far fewer where a human confirmation cannot be afforded.
- jfengel 6y agoWe already use land mines, which are automated weapons. The US is one of the few countries not to sign on to the 1997 Mine Ban Treaty, and its self-imposed restrictions were lifted a year ago. As far as I know they haven't been restored yet.