4 ms·
China voted for the ban of use autonomous weapons. Russia indicated that its willing to sign treaties against their use. So far, the only country that deployed
by sudosysgen 6y ago
China voted for the ban of use autonomous weapons. Russia indicated that its willing to sign treaties against their use.
So far, the only country that deployed an autonomous weapons system is South Korea, a US ally and Israel which is also a US ally.
Russia has only ever deployed defensive autonomous system and fail-deadly nuclear weapons system which even remotely fit the definition.
China has presicely nothing.
Neither China nor Russia is breeding "clone troopers".
From where I'm sitting at, this really seems like barely more than baiting fear using The Foreign Inhuman.
To note, neither Russia nor China have anything to gain relatively from autonomous weapons or "clone troopers" - Russia is at a technological disadvantage in those domains, while China has no plans nor incentives to fight a large scale land war, in which case they would already have more soldiers than they can use, and technoligically is at best matched in autonomous systems with its main adversaries.
- OOvsuOO 6y agowhere is your source. How do you know that china is NOT doing that? You have no idea. Just as we have no idea that the US was building a human tracking system since 9/11 and kept it secret during the wars. Now we know.
- pmiller2 6y agoHow do you know there's not a teapot orbiting the Sun?
- gameman144 6y agoI mean, if the first nation to orbit a teapot around the sun would instantly become a nearly-unstoppable military hegemon, it would be pretty reasonable to assume that there were a secret teapot-orbiting project going on in multiple countries.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere is no such advantage to building autonomous weapons, not at this stage. Where China is so far, their limitation isn't finding the staff to control weapons, and they don't face a situation where expandability is the main issue - their issue is mainly finishing catching up militarily. So the issue is really your premises about it making you "nearly unstoppable", it leads to no such thing. The advantage is much slimmer than you might think, especially right now. As it is, unmanned but non-autonomous weapons provide 99% of the functionality. Additionally, neither the US, Israel, the UK, or Russia are making their autonomous weapons programs secret.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure, it's pretty simple. China doesn't have much to gain from the normalization of autonomous weapons. Beyond that, the US and Russia don't seem to be hiding their work on it, so why would China, which has even less of an incentive, be hiding it?
- throwaway1777 6y agoProof? China, Russia and USA have all lied before about weapons many times. Of course USA should sign the treaty and go on developing the weapon in secret.
- sudosysgen 6y agoProof of what? I can't possibly prove a negative. The facts is that China hasn't deployed any such weapons, while US allies have (deployed weapons are well documented especially when as visible as aircraft and other mass produced vehicles). As for votes and public statements on treaties, that's all public information.
- orbifold 6y agoThis is what China doing nothing looks like https://twitter.com/globaltimesnews/status/1002082247736885248 https://twitter.com/globaltimesnews/status/10020822477368852....
- sudosysgen 6y agoDo you know what's the difference between unmanned and autonomous systems? Almost every country in the world has unmanned weapons. That's not the issue. The issue is autonomous weapons.