4 ms·
Nice story. Not by any means to pick on the Jewish faith, but aren't Rabbis notorious for detailed, obscure, nit-picking arguments that go on forever? Seems li
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Nice story.
Not by any means to pick on the Jewish faith, but aren't Rabbis notorious for detailed, obscure, nit-picking arguments that go on forever? Seems like I remember stories of medieval rabbis getting into the oddest debates.
- lg 18y agoThat describes just about every medieval scholar. Reminds me of pg's essay about philosophy, which (I can independently verify) is mostly true. Though I think the field has gotten a lot more rigorous and interesting in the last few decades because philosophers now specialize to the point where they have enough expertise in their area to say interesting things about it. I can't vouch for present-day rabbis, though.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoPerhaps there is a "Rabbinical Philosophy" course? Somehow I feel there's a Python sketch in there somewhere. Yes. You know philosophy has become specialized when there's a symmetrical relationship between any two topics. We have the history of philosophy, and the philosophy of history. Likewise, we have the philosophy of sociology and the sociology of philosophy. The science of philosophy, and the philosophy of science. I'm hoping to go for the gold and specialize in the sociology of the history of the science of philosophy. I figure there will be one other guy in the world with the same specialty. We can argue by writing papers ad inifinitum. But those medieval guys, sure, they wasted a lot of time. (humor making a point guys)
- lg 18y agoI know what you mean. There's a lot of philosophy going on, and the pressure to publish causes even idiots to write big books and papers. But I think you should judge a field by its most ambitious members and ignore the shadow-world of crappy scholars, journals, and departments that prop each other up for the sake of mutual image-boosting. At good departments, philosophers are expected to be in close contact with fields that their work touches, i.e. if you work on philosophy of physics or law or cognitive science, you should be educated in the field and conversant with its practitioners. But apply that 'judge-by-the-most-ambitious' standard to medieval philosophy and you get angels on pinheads. I think the interdisciplinary people make for more interesting philosophers anyway, even when they aren't using that dual law degree, viz. http://books.google.com/books?id=ZcdIsXrmcPwC&pg=PA33&lpg=PA33&dq=ruth+chang+legal+philosophy&source=web&ots=5e8ZyvI-ew&sig=Xp4DklMbpgKXLRcEnrLe0G_qO4A&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result http://books.google.com/books?id=ZcdIsXrmcPwC&pg=PA33...
- stcredzero 18y agoLike programmers?
- ars 18y agoYes, that's true. There is a discussion in the talmud about the implications (for Shabbat) of having a floating city (in the sky, not water). Judaism is a very logically oriented religion. It's not obvious but every single rules is very logically determined. Except for a specific list that is termed "rules from Sinai". (I don't remember the exact count of how many things are termed so.) Those are like the 'axioms' everything else follows logically from there. It is said that by starting with those rules, the text of the torah, and nothing else, you can regenerate the entire set of laws.
- stcredzero 18y agoThere is a prohibition on floating cities? So adherents cannot live on "seasteads?" Can they work on oil rigs? What about Geoffrey Landis' proposal to colonize the upper atmosphere of Venus by building aerostat habitats there? What about ocean liners with shopping malls and ferris wheels in them?
- ars 18y ago>There is a prohibition on floating cities? What? Hu? Where in the world did I say that? Or even anything close? I said the "implications". Just so it's clear: there is no prohibition for floating cities. The issues discussed were pretty technical, but had to do with public vs. private land on the city.