3 ms·
I'm not a fan of most MS products, and I get a bit of NIH syndrome vibe from the article. However, the security argument is spot on. Perhaps browser developer
by mixmastamyk 15y ago
I'm not a fan of most MS products, and I get a bit of NIH syndrome vibe from the article. However, the security argument is spot on.
Perhaps browser developers have come up with strong countermeasures, but experience shows the state of OS and app development today is still ineffective in the area.
I don't allow Java, most Javascript, and most Flash to run on my system either, so its nothing personal. With direct access to hardware, flakey video drivers, and no thought to security, the possibilities for disaster are even greater with WebGL. Remember Windows has graphics drivers in the kernel.
Also, as long as browsers continue to execute objects on page load instead of behind a play button security breaches will continue.
- georgemcbay 15y ago"Remember Windows has graphics drivers in the kernel" Post-XP, very little of the graphics driver is in the kernel (just the KMD bits). It is mostly all in user space.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoOk, although "when there's a will, there's a way." ;)
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoWhy is deferring execute to a button any better? A user that visits a site is implicitly trusting it; it doesn't take additional trust to click a link (or hover over a link, for that matter). Sandboxing js to only user explicit events will take us back to the browser stone ages.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoIt is much better security/performance-wise to only run programs you intend to. There are sites you visit every day like HN, and there are those sites you rarely if ever visit. Perhaps a link from a link to one of the stories here. Not allowing those sites to autoexecute code is very powerful. Hell, not allowing tracking code to run at trusted sites is just as powerful. With Flashblock et all, I can go to strange urls and not have to worry about dangerous, performance sapping shit getting loaded. There is a whitelist for sites/scripts I choose to enable. If you've never used NoScript/Ghostery give them a try. Your eyes will be opened to the sheer amount garbage loaded even on "trustworthy" sites.