4 ms·
> The truth is that, since music does not denote, the issues of levels of representation and self-reference really do not arise I absolutely disagree. Firstly,
by kazinator 6y ago
> The truth is that, since music does not denote, the issues of levels of representation and self-reference really do not arise
I absolutely disagree. Firstly, music may not denote in the same way as math notation or a sentence of natural language, but it does refer to something external: it triggers sensations in the listener, and it does so in some ways that are objective. For instance, some notes drive satisfyingly ("resolve toward") some other notes, whereas in other situations there is a sense of ambiguity. Using harmonic trickery, the composer can predictably lead the listener around in a labyrinth; the book goes into that.
Secondly, if we accept the premise that music doesn't denote anything external, then we have to confront the remaining fact that music references, and therefore denotes, other music, which is potentially itself. Lack of external reference not only does not preclude self-reference, but emphasizes it as the only interesting option.
Music intersects with computer science, obviously; there are people who do computational music. There are hard problems in music. Bach belongs in that book, because we have not produced a convincing Bach robot.
Why is Escher acceptable but not Bach? An Escher drawing like The Waterfall denotes something: it denotes a nicely drawn piece of architecture denoting an artificial waterfall driving a waterwheel. But the denotation isn't the point; it's the impossibility of the object itself, and of the perpetual motion of the waterwheel. The art has numerous details which don't contribute to that at all. For instance, the waterfall structure has numerous bricks, all carefully drawn. Music is the same. It has sensual aspects, like the timbre of instruments and the expressiveness of the performance, or the power of many instruments in unison and so on. We can't be distracted and fooled by that.