3 ms·
> For the most part, neither the interviewer nor the interview would ever program a LinkedList apart from a few courses in university. And many non-professiona
by Jtsummers 6y ago
> For the most part, neither the interviewer nor the interview would ever program a LinkedList apart from a few courses in university.
And many non-professional athletes going out for a tryout will be put into artificial situations as well instead of being placed on the team and taken to an actual competition for their trial, it doesn't mean that tryouts are fundamentally flawed.
Linked list questions (or other data structure/algorithm questions) are synthetic questions used to gauge competence of individuals because we usually don't get the option to hire someone for a month and try them out in a real world scenario. If they're the sum of the interview, then they're moronic; if they're a portion of the interview, then they're (arguably) reasonable. Certainly more reasonable than the non-programming domain topics you listed.
- tchalla 6y ago> And many non-professional athletes going out for a tryout will be put into artificial situations as well instead of being placed on the team and taken to an actual competition for their trial, it doesn't mean that tryouts are fundamentally flawed. Athletes play games that are universally timed, programmers don't. Besides sportsmen and athletes are regularly tried out in "lower" games before they graduate to a "higher" level. Linked List questions select for university education and memorising problems, not programming. You are making a false binary of "whiteboard or hire for 1 month" which once gain shows laziness as an interviewer. If you are so proficient in your field, you should be able to gauge a competence of an individual from their past work. It shows more about the interviewr that they resort to some cookie-cutter university course questions to decide competence.
- cwilkes 6y agoArtificial situations? Like seeing how fast they can run 40 yards? Can they hit a home run? Can they stop 3 penalty kicks? Sports interviews are way more atuned to the actual job than software interviews.