3 ms·
This is pretty awful, as in mean. Why would you deliberately want to insult someone who hasn't done anything to you? If it's getting them back sure, but as spor
by graderjs 6y ago
This is pretty awful, as in mean. Why would you deliberately want to insult someone who hasn't done anything to you? If it's getting them back sure, but as sport? Just cruel.
Despite all the equations, it seems to me that your work didn't require any real mathematical sophistication. Did I miss something? (This is an especially good ploy if you observe others struggling to understand the talk because they will not want to admit to that after you imply it was easy.)
Isn't this just a straightforward extension of an old result by Hartmanis? (Not even Hartmanis remembers all the theorems Hartmanis proved, but everyone else will assume you remember something they have forgotten.)
Am I missing something here? Can you identify any deep mathematical content in this work? (Once again, audience members who found the talk difficult to understand will be unwilling to admit it.)
Wasn't all this done years ago at Xerox PARC? (No one remembers what was really done at PARC, but everyone else will assume you remember something they don't.)
Have you tested this on the chip Intel got running last week in their lab? (No one knows what
chip Intel got running last week, but everyone will assume you do.)
Am I missing something? Isn't it obvious that there's a bottleneck in the system that prevents scaling to arbitrary size? (This is safe because there's a bottleneck in every system that prevents arbitrary scaling.)
Reminds me of low effort "comments" on Show HNs. Now I'm thinking that maybe people were deliberately trying to be insulting. But why...? Especially when people are being vulnerable sharing their work....
- callesgg 6y agoThe article is supposed to be a joke. If the author did not intend for it to be a joke, you can make the conclusion that the author has psychopathic tendencies.
- graderjs 6y agoRight.... I just didn't read it that way, but i get that some people could. Thanks for pointing it out. It's weird i didn't think there was anything jokey about it, i definitely see this type of thing could be a joke. I just didn't see that there at all. I guess that says more about me and what I'm at that i couldn't see it as a joke...i should probably lighten up I read it like the guy meant it because he felt unfairly sidelined and had some departmental spat with computer scientists...i don't care about that spat, i just thought he was being mean. Maybe it is a meant as a joke... But they say in every joke there's truth, and a lot of comics are the most angry people inside. Humor is their sublimation Edit: i find this one funnier https://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/dec/essay.jargon.html https://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/dec/essay.jargon.html But it definitely has an edge of bitterness within the cs department, as i suspected initially. The themes i read into the first essay are clearly present in the second. I think i was right that this guy has an axe to grind. Just because he writes some supposedly satirical essays doesn't mean he isn't a toxoc person inside or possibly out...
- de_nied 6y agoThis is pretty awful, as in mean. Why would you deliberately want to insult someone who hasn't done anything to you? If it's getting them back sure, but as sport? Just cruel. Despite all the equations, it seems to me that your work didn't require any real mathematical sophistication. Did I miss something? (This is an especially good ploy if you observe others struggling to understand the talk because they will not want to admit to that after you imply it was easy.) Isn't this just a straightforward extension of an old result by Hartmanis? (Not even Hartmanis remembers all the theorems Hartmanis proved, but everyone else will assume you remember something they have forgotten.) Am I missing something here? Can you identify any deep mathematical content in this work? (Once again, audience members who found the talk difficult to understand will be unwilling to admit it.) Wasn't all this done years ago at Xerox PARC? (No one remembers what was really done at PARC, but everyone else will assume you remember something they don't.) Have you tested this on the chip Intel got running last week in their lab? (No one knows what chip Intel got running last week, but everyone will assume you do.) Am I missing something? Isn't it obvious that there's a bottleneck in the system that prevents scaling to arbitrary size? (This is safe because there's a bottleneck in every system that prevents arbitrary scaling.) Reminds me of low effort "comments" on Show HNs. Now I'm thinking that maybe people were deliberately trying to be insulting. But why...? Especially when people are being vulnerable sharing their work....
- graderjs 6y agoWhaat? Your comment is invalid. This is totally different, this is not an insult it's my reaction, don't know you difference? Reaction to this guy issuing instructions on how to be cruel. Now this de_nied guy is objecting to someone calling out bullying uses the schoolyard bullying tactic of repeating the words back to you. What's wrong with you? Unless you're a bully... Or is the de_nied guy the bully who was bullied?