10 ms·
Sleeping octopuses may have dreams, but they're probably brief
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoDo cephalapods dream of aquatic sheep? Would this imply that dreams developed some 500 millions years ago or that the different trees of the animal kingdom both developed the ability?
- scythmic_waves 6y agoConvergent evolution [1] is a pretty fascinating phenomenon! Crazy to think it could happen for something as specific as a brain process like dreaming. Though I guess we all sleep so maybe it's not that crazy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergent_evolution
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoIt really is, especially considering how different the rest of the organism turned out to be.
- cultofmetatron 6y agonot only did they convergently develop an eye similar to ours. It lacks a major flaw that exists in the mammalian version. Theirs has no blind spot!
- tibbydudeza 6y agoWe have color vision thanks our 3 types of cone cells (RGB) while they only one type of cone cell so they see in black and white. Since they can change skin color to match their environment there must be a way they can "see" color. One theory says that their weirdly shaped pupils and brain make up for this deficiency by figuring out the wavelengths of the light in their environment by using chromatic aberration effect.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 6y ago>Would this imply that dreams developed some 500 millions years ago or that the different trees of the animal kingdom both developed the ability? Cephalopods have much, much more complex brains than the other mollusks (such as gastropods or bivalves), so the latter is more likely.
- unfunco 6y agoMany trees/plants have dimethyltryptamine in them, the human experience of taking that chemical is often described as being close to dream-like, I'm not sure if it's relevant though.
- DickingAround 6y agoThey are practically aliens to us, having such a very long ago common ancestor. We can learn a lot about ourselves by studying this alien species and that convergent evolution they have with ours (e.g. sleep). A good, deeper book on this is "Other Minds".
- yawz 6y agoI came here to mention the same thing. Great book. Highly recommended. It talks about this same phenomenon too.
- rodcoelho 6y agoNot to shoot down the findings but anyone with a dog knows that other sentient creatures also dream
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoNot once is it claimed that they are unique in this ability, infact the first line of the article: > Octopuses have alternating periods of "quiet" and "active" sleep that make their rest similar to that of mammals, despite being separated by more than 500 million years of evolution.
- stuntkite 6y agoHow this is being reported annoys me. I read the abstract of the paper. I do not believe the scientists studying this take such a surprised perspective, but are studying extremely technical specifics. I get the need to push the paper out to get some clicks but science journalism needs to be better. "May dream!" Sheesh. I don't have a dog anymore, but I've had a couple that clearly dream. I have several cats that also clearly dream. I suspect my leopard geckos dream because they definitely take a lot of naps. I'm all for this type of study and it appears to be rigorous and interesting. I also believe cephalopods have complex social, spatial, and possibly symbolic dreams like humans have that cats and dogs may not have. But if it sleeps, it dreams. The idea that humans are so far from animals that we can't allow them complex lives full of the same wonder that we allow ourselves is a stupid separation that inhibits understanding and reporting that doesn't equate animal and human consciousness is a stepping stone to determining which humans are human, which historically has worked out poorly. A human exclusive understanding of consciousness is a great way to never be able to talk to our resident or extra-planetary dream having compatriots. The article isn't explicitly surprised, but it really is worded like a feigned surprise when it could be framed in a less annoying way. Maybe I just need a nap.
- monster_group 6y agoAgreed. I once read a "science article" on whales. The article claimed "since whales are not humans, they cannot be lonely and therefore..." blah blah. I closed the article, immediately after I read that statement. Pretentiousness of humans is mind boggling.
- stuntkite 6y agoLike giant mammals that have something close to the internet via aquatic sound transmission since before we got out of trees can't be a beautiful and complex psychic profusion. They must be chumps! These assholes didn't even invent money! Something something Star Trek IV.
- CameronNemo 6y agoIf they had the internet before us, they could have just skipped the metal and paper money steps and skipped right to a group maintained ledger.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- erulabs 6y agoI fully believe that discovering the function of sleep and of dreams will go extremely far to understanding the function of consciousness. Evolutionary psychology ("genetic epistemology") is increasingly becoming the most interesting thing I've ever read about. Particularly the work of Jean Piaget. Everyone knows plenty of animals dream, so I'm looking forward to having the time to read the actual whitepaper here!
- dvh 6y agoIt's been a while since I have parakeet but I think birds also dream.
- phcordner 6y agoThe human-octopus most recent common ancestor was an ancient organism from hundreds of million years ago. It would have been one of the earlier organisms to have bilateral symmetry and an embryonic development characterized by the three germ layers we have today. If you have a dog and have been to the aquarium you're likely to already intuit that octopuses do something that looks a lot like sleeping and that animals all the way down the family tree have periods of quiet and active sleep as well. The researchers here use a combination of observational techniques to suggest that the octopus sleep states observed are analogous to sleep in the vertebrate. The research paper as published does not explicitly mention dreaming, rather it is one of a host of processes implied when the researchers analogize the 'active sleep' behavior observed in the octopus to animal REM sleep patterns. The conclusion spells out the possible connection to the 'metabolic detoxification' and 'cognitive processing' functions of vertebrate REM sleep but does not state them definitively. The general media news article and the research paper have some slight differences because of their different intended audiences, but litigating that divide is best left to those already doing it: the esteemed scholars of the Dunning-Krueger Institute at Wikipedia University.
- coss 6y agoI watched My Octopus Teacher and it really opened my eyes to how smart they are. Watching the Octopus play with the fish conducting a symphony was so beautiful to watch. Was on the edge of my seat when it was evading the predator as well.
- ashurbanipal 6y agoChildren of Ruin
- cperciva 6y ago*octopodes