2 ms·
Row erupts over university’s use of research metrics in job-cut decisions
- PaulHoule 6y agoI read a "paper" Steve Wolfram wrote about the S and K-Kombinators and got a little depressed. On one hand Steve Wolfram has too much and has no pressure to do anything relevant so he gets some idea like "I'm going to try to write every possible computer program and see what happens" knowing perfectly well it proves nothing (he cites the theorems.) From a pedagogy standpoint I would send him to look at "To Mock a Mockingbird" and try again. His physics program is half-brilliant and half-baked. Causal nets capture the one thing we really "know" about space-time. What he doesn't tell you is that there is no real problem doing calculations over quantum gravity and none of what he is doing is really that fresh (e.g. people use strings, loop quantum gravity, and many other methods to investigate "the first 10^-43 seconds"; that plus a particle accelerator the size of the Milky Way wins you a Nobel Prize... That is, the "problem" is picking one of the many results that have some part of the universe that at least superficially past what we see looking back in time.) If he got some discipline and tough love, fought with some peer reviewers, remembered the anxiety of being an Assistant Professor, had to rewrite a grant proposal three times (vastly improving it on each round) to get it funded and such he might do better work. Meanwhile the real assistant professor is so worried about getting tenure that one day he cracks up. Human knowledge could be advanced by a number of 0.5-2 FTE*year projects that never get funded. And then there is the humanities, where you have to pass as understanding James Joyce on the way to an English PhD to make literature seem as exclusive as quantum mechanics, to make "French Theory" seem like something that was made to make other people feel stupid.