3 ms·
I've given a lot of thought to this issue and though I've wanted to give Richard Stallman the benefit of the doubt, I've come to an inescapable conclusion: The
by bitwize 6y ago
I've given a lot of thought to this issue and though I've wanted to give Richard Stallman the benefit of the doubt, I've come to an inescapable conclusion:
The FSF board of directors really stepped in it bringing Stallman back, especially in the clandestine manner that they did. They have squandered the goodwill of the community by promoting a controversial figure known for his toxic opinions and decades of bad behavior to a leadership position. The FSF is at grave risk of losing its funding and its reputation, both of which it needs to carry out its mission.
As such, it is appropriate for Stallman and the entire FSF board to resign. John Sullivan has made the right decision. He will doubtless be followed by others -- and hopefully, if Stallman refuses to resign, he will be ousted by the new board.
All of the leadership in open source does not want Stallman in a leadership role because of the toxic effect he has on the community, in particular driving women -- and more recently, those repulsed by pedophilia -- away. There are times to fight social pressure; this is not one of them.
- Number157 6y agoThis community is toxic and drives good but flawed people away.
- bitwize 6y agoA talented asshole is a net liability. An untalented, nontoxic person can become a valuable contributor with the right training and mentoring.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ionwake 6y agoSurely this is not the case if the talented asshole has already contributed in a massively vast way to the team / society.
- orra 6y agoAdditionally, an asshole can drive away multiple people. Even if an asshole is three times as productive as your typical contributor, they can easily drive away ten people. Not to mention the morality of pedestalling creeps.
- platonq 6y agoExcept that these 10 people never materialize if someone who has made 10 "wrong" statements in a decade is canceled. Which is why cancel tactics are employed only in mature code bases, and the 10 people who do materialize are power hungry bureaucrats who associate themselves with the work of others for financial gain.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ionwake 6y agoHi bitwize, if one wanted to see a damning piece of evidence of these accusations, can you link to a page discussing said evidence? Or is this an opinion expressed by you knowing him personally?
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y ago> because of the toxic effect he has on the community, in particular driving women -- and more recently, those repulsed by pedophilia -- away. Can you name one person who was driven away from contributing to free software because of Stallman? Sarah Mei? Lol. I believe that it is unlikely for someone _really_ willing to contribute to society to abandon this idea simply because some person he's never met being an unpleasant person. If that really turned someone off, the desire to participate was weaker than mild.
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoWhat absurd nonsense. If you see a community supporting opinions you hold vile, you will simply go and join a less toxic community. This attitude that FLOSS supporters should be dedicated to the cause no matter the cost is why the GCC and copyleft communities are dying.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoIn FLOSS nobody cares who you are. Not your sex, your gender, not even your real identity. All that matters is the value you provide, mostly in the form of code. Those who contribute good code are lauded, others - not so much. If you are seeking things like recognition, acknowledgement or other ways to entertain your vanity, you should really join some other community. FLOSS could use more engineers and fewer activists who contribute only to the community, not to the code or documentation/teaching materials. Also, copyleft communities are not dying. They are fine and growing.
- viraptor 6y agoCreating new free software has nothing to do with RMS. (From the software side, he had impact on licensing) People did it before him and will continue after him, many without knowing who RMS is. More likely effect is closer to "This conference invited RMS? No thanks." from both potential attendees and speakers. Supporting FSF will also be less likely.
- Qwertious 6y agoOoh. Blaming the user for not contributing to a political organization for political reasons? lol
- 533474 6y agoIf you really want to give him the benefit of doubt, I suggest reading this [1] [1] https://www.wetheweb.org/post/cancel-we-the-web https://www.wetheweb.org/post/cancel-we-the-web
- toolz 6y agogreat read, I learned a lot and I especially enjoyed the writings from Nadine Strossen, she seems to touch on what may be a core reason for a lot of my frustration with todays political landscape.
- thinkingemote 6y ago> open source There are many in the FSF that view the aims of "open source" as opposite to Free Software. FSF aims for the elimination of all proprietary software. Microsoft and IBM support open source and the resignation of the FSF board. Open Source has basically won. No one really gets what Free Software is anymore.
- orra 6y agoThat's not the issue here. FSFE have condemned the FSF, for example.
- thinkingemote 6y agoBitwise's comment says that it's the open source community which is being harmed. FSF is Free Software - the FSF don't view the Open Source community as their support base. But open source broadly views free software as part of themselves.