3 ms·
Now that would be an epic Streisand effect. This genie isn’t going back in the bottle.
by Havoc 6y ago
Now that would be an epic Streisand effect. This genie isn’t going back in the bottle.
- ben_w 6y agoIf the currency is banned, only criminals will accept it or sell it. How often do you you expect Jane and Joe Average to actively choose to trade with criminal businesses? (Other than for illegal drugs, which I recognise are way more commonly used than pearl-clutching newspapers and politicians pretend).
- coldtea 6y ago>Now that would be an epic Streisand effect Nope. Streisand effect is about not being able to keep something off the media/press/gossip/etc when you try to make it so. It's not about the inability to make something illegal and be succesful at it (because of what? many people learning about the law? That's a bonus for laws). >This genie isn’t going back in the bottle It very easily can: "You have 6 months to register your bitcoin with the authorities and covert it to dollars and/or pay taxes on it. If you still have such addresses after that you'll be illegal. Exchanges should ceaze operations immediately".
- csomar 6y ago> covert it to dollars convert it with whom? US government? Foreign investors?
- ben_w 6y agoWould it matter? In the most extreme case — if mere possession has a penalty in law — BTC could even have a negative price. People could conceivably sell it to their own government below zero to avoid being fined by the same.
- coldtea 6y agoI think the concern of the parent is "but why would the government exchange it, since they're making it illegal, and at what price -- since the act of making it illegal will get it into free-fall anyway". And it might not -- if that was the case, the owner would have to try to sell it to wherever they can within the time span. Which would also mean a flooded market and falling prices, but why would the government care about that? In the end, they get a tax share of the smaller, dollar converted, amount. As for the bitcoin owners losing money because of this, well, that money were in the form of a monetary asset that was not guaranteed by the government, in the first place. It's not like they lost private property, more like they made a bad (non-)investment...
- ben_w 6y agoTaxes are not the only reason a government may wish to ban it. The reason governments left the Gold Standard was for the control it gave them over the economy — ironically that control seems to be one of the rhetorical arguments BTC supporters give for wanting to ditch fiat currencies.