4 ms·
> I mean, people still read Jane Austen's six novels about the interpersonal relationships of characters from 200 years ago who didn't have to work for a living
by vidarh 6y ago
> I mean, people still read Jane Austen's six novels about the interpersonal relationships of characters from 200 years ago who didn't have to work for a living and had all their material needs met (though they were obsessed with wealth, so the parallel isn't exact).
Jane Austen-like novels set in a world where wealth is no object and people change gender/sex and physical appearance at will has the scope for whole new levels of confusion...
> That's interesting! What on earth did they expect Banks's politics would be?
There's a bizarre paradox in especially American views of socialism, where some people dismisses socialist goals as utopian and from that draws the conclusion that the only way a society could be like that is if there's either a capitalist machinery hiding under a carpet somewhere, or authoritarian socialist government agents lurking in the corner.
Often these people are unaware of left-wing libertarianism (anarchists, libertarian Marxists, and a whole range of other "small to no government" socialists), and so they tend to find it hard to even imagine a socialist that wants a small state or no state at all and see talk of that as a ruse.
I think they've been raised by the expectations of a lot of dystopian works that presents a "utopia on the surface" (HG Wells "The Time Machine" being one of the early explicit examples) to look for cracks, and basically assume we can't have good things. When they're then also sceptical of socialism, they have a perception of a mode of how such an expected dystopia should look like "under the hood"