2 ms·
So I admit that this is totally based on outside optics only, but everything I've seen signals "big corporate group thing" similar to many standard groups and o
by detaro 6y ago
So I admit that this is totally based on outside optics only, but everything I've seen signals "big corporate group thing" similar to many standard groups and other committees, which is fun and games if participating is your job: you get an opportunity to talk about about what you are doing on company time, with peers that are also there on company time and thus don't mind spending hours on participating in meetings (during work time, because it's work for everyone else), reading mailing-lists, ... But if you aren't paid for it, you either need to have effectively unlimited free time or be someone highly respected already to be able to participate on a meaningful level.
If that's not the goal, you need to invest into a) ensuring that you actually do provide a useful environment for outside participants and b) communicating this, i.e. by having a public presence that clearly explains this and doesn't look like it's targeted at impressing middle management. Transparency into what is going on right now is key to this.
"Linux Foundation" doesn't scream "community". See also other comments here specifically about Google's input, which reads a lot like "we've thought up some things we're now going to impose on everyone, just open-washed a bit". (Again, this is totally outside image, and not intended as an attack on any individual involved as having done anthing wrong, just trying to communicate what outside impression you are likely dealing with)