3 ms·
A lot of Americans of any gender would be put off by a lot of very routine and candid professional communications that happen in Germany. I find American Engli
by sneak 6y ago
A lot of Americans of any gender would be put off by a lot of very routine and candid professional communications that happen in Germany. I find American English in general to be tending toward the near universal avoidance of direct speech and statements, independent of speaker/listener identity.
Importantly the speaker and listener are not consciously aware of this happening. The net result is that you can say literal/plain thing A and the listener can hear literal/plain thing B.
Speaking to Americans requires a significantly accurate modeling of the listener's mind and expectations to be able to be clearly understood, much much moreso than any other language I have studied or even heard of.
Basically, it is very easy to be totally misunderstood when using plain, literal speech (such as is common in Germany or in Slavic countries).
I've written about it: https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/ https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/
- bonoboTP 6y agoHow does this play out in American companies with lots of employees from Europe and other places?
- qihqi 6y agoI used to work for a company that has the standard "Meet Expectations" / "Exceeds Expectations" performance review every 6 month. Some European coworker felt the need to make a ppt titled 'euro-perf' to teach Europeans how to write performance feedback. Apparently words like "Good", "OK", "decent" etc meant slightly below median, and words like "Amazing" meant slightly above median for Americans. An European coworker also told me that he used to think a solid track record of Meet Expectations is very good and worthy of a promotion.
- bonoboTP 6y agoYeah I find American exaggeration (over-positivity) quite tiring. Good things become "amazing" and "literally the best ever". Even "great" is just around median in actual meaning. Everyone is "excited" to meet you and "thrilled" about whatever you say, wide smiles etc. Complaining about anything is a huge no-no, your life narrative must always be carefully crafted and anything slightly negative rephrased as a positive challenge and learning opportunity. Everyone is a hero sitting on a great exponential upward curve ahead of them. You are considered negative and a downer for just not buzzing all the time. Seems like people care even more about "saving face" than in East Asia.
- novok 6y agoIt's really industry and region specific. Some parts of america are very direct.
- disposekinetics 6y agoThank you for writing that article. I'm a native English speaker and I intend to speaker clearer because I read this.
- sneak 6y agoPleased to help speaker more clearer. That goal.
- soared 6y agoVery interesting to read. I wonder if some of this is due to neutral statements in English tending to carry a negative connotation. If I say "I want to come over tomorrow but I'm not sure if I can make it" - that actually means "I do not want to come over tomorrow". You /can't/ communicate without euphemisms, and trying to will always fail and make you seem like a dick even though you're just being straightforward. That is likely where the difficulty you've experienced comes from. (For context, your exact situation occurred this weekend. I was invited to an event and said yes, but both me and my friend knew that I would not attend)
- sneak 6y agoYou shouldn't lie in a response to an invitation.
- bombcar 6y agoWe’re lost the formal flowery language of the English which was designed to communicate things like this more precisely - “I regret that I will be unable to attend but I appreciate the invitation and cherish our relationship” or similar.
- Kye 6y agoModern English is perfectly capable of handling this. "I can't make it, but I appreciate the offer."
- soared 6y agoI think you misunderstood? If the message being conveyed is understood by everyone involved it’s not a lie. Your post can claim the words are a lie I guess, but not in this culture.
- Khaine 6y agoNo, its cultural. Australians and Brits don't suffer from the same over-the-top positivity for positivity sake
- uvnq 6y agoAs an American concerned about the direction our language (and our culture) is headed in, realizing that there are places in the west that aren't like this is incredibly relieving.