4 ms·
> This made Amazon look quite childish honestly. Don't you think it makes Warren look childish? She said she wants to break up big tech companies so that they
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> This made Amazon look quite childish honestly.
Don't you think it makes Warren look childish? She said she wants to break up big tech companies so that they aren't able to challenge her. I think that's an absolutely appalling thing for a lawmaker to say. Warren should be defending their right to challenger her, not attacking it, and she should be empowering institutions to challenge her, not attacking those that are. I can't understand how anyone is defending this craziness. It's chilling.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIf I have to choose to defend someone, it’s not Amazon and Bezos. He and chosen management had a choice on what sort of company and culture to build. Choose poorly and then be surprised when government and the public come after you? Relentlessly tactless and tone deaf.
- chrisseaton 6y agoInstitutions should have the right to challenge lawmakers without thread of retribution for doing so, even if you don't like what they have to say.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoAgreed, but I also agree with Warren that Amazon should be broken up. Warren’s stance pales in comparison to the machine of suffering that is Amazon fulfillment/retail. Nuance and pragmatism.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDoes she want to break them up for for the benefit of the people she represents, or does she want to break them up because they're 'snotty' to her? She's explicitly said it's because of the latter. I hope it's because of the former, but I have to trust her own words are lies to believe that!
- busterarm 6y ago...Elizabeth Warren is a serial liar.
- busterarm 6y agoWarren isn't exactly mainstream government. She can't even get her "progressive" credentials consistent as she rarely misses an opportunity to be the hawk. She sure loves those foreign wars.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThey aren’t making a whole lot of new conservatives in America. Centrist Democrats are either aging out or getting pushed out. Change takes time. Gotta defend against people like Bezos in the meantime ($187B? and still throwing a childish fit about your workers trying to have better working conditions? Really?).
- busterarm 6y agoNone of that makes Warren above criticism. And if you think America isn't minting a lot of new conservatives, I think you've been sleeping the last 6 years. Conservatives just had the biggest voter turnout that they've had since Ronald Reagan. And despite our Gen X/Millenial social circles which are heavily left, Zoomers are much more conservative than us.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou were attacking and criticizing Warren (not I, as I focused on parties driven by ideas and moors), which doesn’t concern me and has little value regardless unless you vote in her state. The greater issue is what happens when speaking truth to power garners contempt and harm instead of cooperation and humility. Enter regulation, stage right.
- busterarm 6y agoWould you not say that Amazon's critical tweet of Warren was speaking truth to power?
- toomuchtodo 6y ago
- paulryanrogers 6y agoLegislators shouldn't be afraid of challengers. That said, it's reasonable to fear corporations with so many resources they capture regulators and can bankroll astroturfed challengers. I'd like both a balanced, accountable government and healthy, competitive markets please.
- elil17 6y agoWhy should big tech companies be able to challenge democratically elected representatives? Shouldn't political participation be primarily in the hands of people, not special interests? I get that the question of whether corporations should have a role in politics is up for debate, but I think most of the people who elected Warren believe that there's no place for big money in politics.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Why should big tech companies be able to challenge democratically elected representatives? Every person and every (legal) institution should be able to (verbally and in writing) challenge a democratically elected representative. I can't understand why that even needs stating? She's literally threatening legislative retribution for being "snotty" to her. That's appalling, surely?
- elil17 6y agoIf Warren said that to a person I think it would absolutely be appalling and I get that in the current US legal system corporations have a right to free speech. I just don't think that's an intrinsic moral right the way it is for people. I think it's a valid, reasonable view that Amazon should not be able to influence politics in any way.
- HomeDeLaPot 6y agoOne way to interpret Warren's tweet is "she doesn't believe that private corporations should have the ability to stand up to politicians." Another way is "she realizes that Amazon has so much political influence that it can tweet anything it wants at elected representatives without any consequences." So which is it? Is Amazon a private American corporation on equal footing with the government, simply exercising free speech, and evil Warren wants to stifle them? Or is Amazon an evil giant corporation making a PR power play because it has so much underhanded influence in politics and public opinion that it is guaranteed to make this end badly for Warren or anyone else who opposes them, and Warren is just looking to put them in check?