4 ms·
>The Culture is neoconservatism on the greatest imaginable scale. Exactly this. It was one of the first thoughts I had when people introduced me to the Culture
by Barrin92 6y ago
>The Culture is neoconservatism on the greatest imaginable scale.
Exactly this. It was one of the first thoughts I had when people introduced me to the Culture and pitched it to me as a sort of socialist utopia.
I don't even think Banks is aware of this himself given his own takes quoted in the article but the The Culture fundamentally isn't a futurist utopia but a socially engineered, materially abundant liberal 19th century experiment in the broad sense of the term extrapolated into the future.
All difficult problems are effectively outsourced to the Minds, even language is understood in a Sapir–Whorf way as a tool to exercise social control. Criminals aren't punished but ostracized and neutered in an 'enlightened' way. Individual hedonism is basically the only activity left for people to engage in.
A lot of the problems of the Culture haven't vanished but been outsourced to a kind of space CIA in the form of 'Special Circumstances' which does all the ugly stuff the happy people of the Culture don't want to deal with. Outwardly the culture is very aggressive in its attempts to assimilate everyone incompatible with the Culture. Contact between the Culture and other civilizations often leads to covert conflict. Player of Games being probably the best example, where the Culture basically sends a Bobby Fischer style character to a 'backwards' empire to use a game competition as a means to topple the regime from within.
And for democracy in the Culture itself, even though in the eyes of the people the Minds are supposed to be a sort of magical democracy solving technology that just builds consensus in fair ways, we also learn that the Minds very much have minds of their own (no pun intended) in the book (can't remember the title) that tells the story to us from their perspective.
Banks in general seems to me like Trotskyist who turned from Communist to Neocon (a very common phenomenon), with the twist that he doesn't really seem to be aware of it at all and thinks he's actually writing a genuine utopia. I've always liked that about the books the most because it actually in many ways to me makes the Culture a really good dystopian work where the author rather than trying to write one is actually trying to trick you into liking the Culture.
- perardi 6y ago…Minds very much have minds of their own (no pun intended) in the book (can't remember the title)… Possibly Excession, which featured Minds at their most…well, I’d argue human. Their desire for [space McGuffin] does not end up being a good look for the Interesting Times gang.
- JetSetWilly 6y agoI think Banks very much was aware of everything you say. In fact reading The Culture as an allegory for the USA/The West is one of the most common interpretations of the The Culture, including by Banks.