3 ms·
I think that you may be missing that Banks' series is actually about this very contradiction. He continually explores just how hypocritical, contradictory, and
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
I think that you may be missing that Banks' series is actually about this very contradiction. He continually explores just how hypocritical, contradictory, and partial the "utopia" in the Culture actually is. His Minds are clever, but they have built-in biases. The majority of citizens are "happy" but his books explore the corner cases and there are plenty of characters shown to have ennui or some sense of resent. The first of the series (Consider Phlebas) involves a non-Culture character who despises the Culture for precisely this groundlessness. And all of his books in the Culture involve the "Special Circumstances" organization in some aspect, poking their fingers in places where they arguably should not be (but sometimes should be).
In his books the Culture is simultaneously a "good guy" but also an overbearing preachy and hypocritical and sometimes ethically dubious plot foil.
The actual "bad guys" (imperialist hierarchical tyrannical aliens, etc.) are shown in a very bad light, but in the process of dealing with them, the ugly side of the Culture is constantly shown.