3 ms·
Well there is a value, albeit a small one. Bitcoin is a ledger. If you hired an accounting firm to keep track of who had which assets and handled transactions
by colechristensen 6y ago
Well there is a value, albeit a small one.
Bitcoin is a ledger.
If you hired an accounting firm to keep track of who had which assets and handled transactions, there is value being created... valuable work being done.
This value probably isn't being generated very efficiently (there's an interesting study to do, actually figure this out and don't rely on somebody's intuition) and the "value" isn't being actually utilized very widely: how much of bitcoin being used doesn't fall into the categories of A) generally morally objectionable B) toy uses fiat -> BTC -> txn -> fiat which didn't need the BTC middleman or C) speculation. [ not much ]
Mining bitcoin would seem to transform a lot of electricity into a little accounting, not free of value, but likely demonstrably of low value.
- nly 6y agoKeeping a ledger of billions of participants making billions of transactions is a solved problem, and has basically zero cost when amortized over its utility. In 2020 VISA handled 3.5 billion accounts (cards), 140 billion transactions and $11.3 trillion in volume. Total operating expenses were $7.7bn, so just 0.07% of transaction volume. At current prices, just the block rewards make the Bitcoin network running cost something like $37bn/year. As a ledger it's strictly inferior in every way. (The ability to take bitcoin 'offline' by holding your private key, or exchanging it on secondary markets, is not a feature of the blockchain itself. These features can exist without a blockchain).
- berkes 6y agoHow does a Somali web dev get a Visa to pay for her servers or domain registrations? How will a Syrian restaurant owner accept Mastercard payments from his custumers? How can Wikileaks accept donations? Do you not consider those 'economic value'?
- nly 6y agoSure it's valuable, but it's hardly significant. You're talking about tiny fractions of a % of the global economy.
- colechristensen 6y agoUltimately I pay Visa etc. roughly 3% (the retailer "pays" but certainly passes that cost on to me) of all of my card transactions, which is the vast majority of money I spend outside of rent. I wonder where the 50x difference goes. > At current prices, just the block rewards make the Bitcoin network running cost something like $37bn/year. The block rewards are "free", it is hard to come up with a way to account for the cost of something which is invented from thin air. The better comparison would be how much the electricity and mining hardware per year is used compared to the transaction work done. Logic would say, though, that the money spent mining and the BTC->USD value of block rewards would be similar (that is the margins on bitcoin mining tend towards zero). However with the volatile pricing of bitcoin, you would have to generate a BTC->USD value for each block reward and not convert a year's worth of rewards on a particular day's (or minute's) spot price.
- nly 6y ago> Ultimately I pay Visa etc. roughly 3% It would be the same with Bitcoin. Retailers have no interest in eyeballing the Bitcoin exchange rate and dynamically repricing their goods every 5 minutes. Unless Bitcoin becomes price stable, or the currency in which they pay all their expenses, they'll always be deferring to payment processors. Bitpay charge 1%, which isn't even that cheap. > The block rewards are "free", it is hard to come up with a way to account for the cost of something which is invented from thin air. It's not "free". They spent a fortune in amortized equipment costs and energy to win that reward. The bottom line is the miners need to sell their 12.5 BTC block rewards to cover their real world costs (+profit). So, in a competitive mining environment, the block reward coupled with the market price is a proxy for the minimum cost of running the network. This is one factor in market prices.
- literallycancer 6y agoCredit cards are not permissionless and the settlement is delayed by days.
- nly 6y agoInstant settlement doesn't necessarily provide 'value'. I can arrive at a store entrance, and in 30 seconds be leaving with a new macbook, paid for on my VISA card. I can then pay it off 56 days later without paying any charges or interest. If i couldn't do this the store would almost certainly make fewer sales.
- lmilcin 6y ago> Well there is a value, albeit a small one. > Bitcoin is a ledger. This is false. Let's say I am shady business that launders money. Is bitcoin helping stop my laundering? No... I just use regular money which can't be tracked so easily... In essence, bitcoin makes it easier to track money of people who don't mind their money is being tracked or are inept enough to understand their money can be traced.
- colechristensen 6y agoHow does any of that refute the claim that there is value in what bitcoin does or that it is a ledger? (who can deny that bitcoin is a ledger anyway? I'd like to see somebody define a ledger and what bitcoin does and show the contradiction)
- lmilcin 6y agoI work with accounting systems on daily basis and also have accounting background. Ledger does not replace need for accountants. We already have a bunch of software for ledger (that also doesn't require to burn huge amounts of energy). Banks are ledger and if somebody like a government want to get info from that ledger it has been quite easy recently -- even Swiss banks relented and have been forced to submit information. Accountants are people who specialize in knowing how to categorize stuff before it is put on a ledger in a way that meets requirements of local law and makes business more easy to conduct. I don't see any possible way in which bitcoin is making this easier.
- colechristensen 6y agoI'm not making the claim that bitcoin replaces an accounting firm? >I don't see any possible way in which bitcoin is making this easier. Who says it has to be easier or better? It does the work of handling transactions and keeping track of balances. With bitcoin as a user you only have to pay a very tiny transaction fee in order to keep track of your account value and handle the transfer from one account to another. Is this better? Well you don't have to pay somebody to operate software and as long as you can access the bitcoin network there aren't any impediments to doing transactions. But the point isn't if bitcoin is better or best or even good, just that is does the thing and doing that thing has value.