8 ms·
"It’s interesting that they don’t entertain the possibility that the gap might be caused by something other than bias" Imagine a medicinal study that would con
by inglor_cz 6y ago
"It’s interesting that they don’t entertain the possibility that the gap might be caused by something other than bias"
Imagine a medicinal study that would concentrate on the hypothesis that sinners get cholera as a divine retribution for their sinful lives, and would not even entertain other possible causes, such as ... dirty drinking water.
We would rightly locate such a study into, say, 1840, but definitely not 2021.
That is where authors of this study belong mentally. Into the science of the era when Lincoln was young.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> We would rightly locate such a study into, say, 1840, but definitely not 2021. You give far too little credit to 1840 and far too much to 2021.
- inglor_cz 6y agoLook up 1854 Broad Street cholera outbreak. That was when the scientific breakthrough regarding bad water took place - and many actually refused to accept the results. Before that, the most "scientific" theory about cholera outbreaks was the miasma theory, but religious and pseudoreligious beliefs about divine punishment or influence of the stars were not fringe yet.
- throwaway894345 6y agoTo be clear, my earlier comment was made in jest. I’m familiar with the Broad Street outbreak, but I’m not aware that religious theories were commonplace among scientists of the time. Notably that science wasn’t taken seriously by society more broadly doesn’t mean that the science of the time was “tainted by religion” (I say this as a religious person). Perhaps we’re making different points: mine is that science today is contaminated by a fervor resembling religion (though I don’t want to overstate the problem—overwhelmingly I think the effect is very low for the time being and I suspect it is highest in areas that are most pertinent to the ideology in question, which thankfully tends not yet to be the hard sciences or engineering disciplines lest our bridges fail, buildings collapse, and rockets explode on the launchpad).