3 ms·
I'm so happy that other people start to notice this dynamic. Why are we not yet fully running on renewables? Why don't we have trillions of dollars pouring int
by scotty79 6y ago
I'm so happy that other people start to notice this dynamic.
Why are we not yet fully running on renewables? Why don't we have trillions of dollars pouring into solar panels and wind turbines and pumped storage hydroelectricity and battery storage?
The answer is there's not enough demand for excess electricity to create and keep excess electricity. I read about new pumped storage hydroelectricity installation closed due to lack of demand. There are too few ways to turn excess electricity into money. If we are going to have fully renewable energy in the future, we need to produce way more energy than we need so when conditions are bad for power generation we still have enough. And for that we need incentives. We are struggling to create artificial, law based incentives on global scale.
Cryptos are currently the best way we have to organically create those incentives. There were already instances of crypto miners selling energy they contracted, back to the grid, when price of energy briefly exceeded the gain they could have by burning that energy to mine.
When prices of crypto rise again in few years and hardware hashrate plateaus we may reach a point when miners will be building/buying new windmill and solar panel installations on mass scale, because their costs will be dominated by the energy costs and the cheapest energy will be excess energy renewables produce.
We don't lack resources to reach the green future, we lack incentives, and if we are lucky meteoric rise of price of crypto can provide those.
EDIT: And the post is flagged into oblivion. I'm no longer happy because interesting observation got silenced. Well I guess see you all in few years.
EDIT2: .... and now it's unflagged. :-) A hot topic.
- xiphias2 6y agoWhat about training ML models as another example? It requires a lot of energy as well (and I expect it to be more significant in the future), and the optimal power draw should depend on the price of energy. Of course it requires GPU/TPU pricing to change depending on clock speed, which is hard to sell to customers. So yeah, for now Bitcoin mining is a more scalable solution.
- scotty79 6y agoSure. That's also great if you can monetize trained ML models so easily that everyone can participate. It's already being done to some very small degree by few companies that locate their ML server farms in places where energy is cheap and renewable. I hope this application will some day compete with crypto for computing power and energy and win but I don't think it will be popularized and commoditized soon enough to bring money into green energy. I hopefully await headlines "ML training now uses as much energy as Australia". If you could create crypto based on ML training it would be so cool.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 6y ago,,If you could create crypto based on ML training it would be so cool.'' That would actually be a bad thing: the real value in proof of work is that it doesn't have any extra value to the miner, which stops miners from gaining a huge edge over other possible future miners. What's behind all the controversy is that proof of work has to be totally useless work, that's what makes it valuable for the blockchain :)
- intotheabyss 6y agoIn proof of stake, you can slash validators that attempt to re-org the mem pool for MEV. Fast finality of a few seconds also helps.
- scotty79 6y agoCould you direct me to more elaborate discussion why work in proof of work must be useless? Am I wrong thinking that any problem with hard to find, but easily verifiable solution, should be ok? It would be nice if it had easily adjustable difficulty to scale it with processing power of the miners.
- Vhano 6y agois this baby's first bitcoin day out?
- jokethrowaway 6y agoIt's not because we consume too little electricity: it's because it's not convenient just yet (but we're getting there thanks to tech advance). The less energy we use the better for now, given that part of that energy will be "dirty".
- scotty79 6y agoMain reason we don't develop renewables faster is storage capacity. And storage capacity technologies we can create are oscillating around break even point economically. There's no gold rush to place energy storage system everywhere and it's not obviously economically profitable. However variable load such as crypto mining provides similar incentives as energy storage. And there is a crypto gold rush.
- bootlooped 6y agoI think the flaw in this is that crypto mining will take place regardless of whether the source of the electricity is green or not, and regardless of whether the electricity is excess capacity or not. Crypto mining is a business; they may find it beneficial to mine during both peak and off-peak hours, and they're unlikely to care whether the electricity is coming from wind or coal, so long as it's cheap enough to turn a profit. So as a side effect, yeah, it may make building new renewable sources more feasible, but it's a big shotgun and there's a lot of collateral damage.