3 ms·
Root comment: >>> how about the NSA used its powers to defend Americans instead of hoarding zero days and spying on them? >> why does this have to be XOR? Be
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
Root comment:
>>> how about the NSA used its powers to defend Americans instead of hoarding zero days and spying on them?
>> why does this have to be XOR?
Because these are opposed goals. Defending Americans means invalidating zero-days. You could restrict yourself solely to attacks that don't rely on flaws in the software. In that case, you would have no reason to hoard zero-days, because you are ideologically committed to never use them.
That would be weird in a few different ways. But most relevant here, it answers "Why can't we do both?" with "We can, as long as we never do the second one!"
This is not really a compelling response.
- colordrops 6y agoBut this isn't answering my question - why aren't they opposed goals for other parts of the military? Why just cyber? And we've already addressed the question of exposing ourselves - attacks can targeted and not universal, just like physical attacks. This property is not specific to cyber. For the inverse, the military could decide to use a bioweapon, but it would also attack ourselves.