6 ms·
Hacker News Job Board?
I'm thinking of setting up a job board that only people who are Hacker News users can post to. I would use the same arc code that is used for HN, but this board would be open to the non-YC companies.
To authenticate your account you would need to:
1. Create an account on the jobs board with the same name as your HN username
2. Place a magic string in your HN about: box to prove that it was you
3. Have at least 200 karma or have been an HN member for more than 2 years
4. Unauthenticated accounts could still comment, vote etc., just not submit jobs.
Would people use this?
- ColinWright 15y agoI'd certainly register, look at it, and play with it a bit.
- latch 15y agoUnfortunately, I need to post a "me too" comment to let the OP know (I can't just upvote anymore!)
- kristofferR 15y agoYeah, I agree too.
- robinwarren 15y agoNice idea, and given I've had success hiring through a HN who's Hiring thread in the past I'd very likely use it. I had been working on a job board project of my own (http://www.jobstractor.com http://www.jobstractor.com) but have struggled with traction to date. I think there's definitely opportunities for better jobs boards and especially for cutting out recruiters from the process. If I can lend a hand let me know and I'll do what I can.
- wccrawford 15y agoWhat's the thinking on the limitations? Is this just supposed to make the users think they are part of an elite bunch? Are the employers supposed to think that somehow selects only elite hackers?
- verroq 15y agoObviously to benefit the early adopters. /sarcasm
- jgrahamc 15y agoThe biggest problem with job boards is... recruiters. The idea here is that members in good-standing of the HN community are unlikely to be recruiters and thus can be trusted to freely post jobs to the board. If it was open to anyone then it would be flooded with crap immediately.
- wccrawford 15y agoSoo... Instead of employers or recruiters posting jobs, employees (specifically hackers) would post the jobs on behalf of their companies?
- jgrahamc 15y agoYes, but also employers. There are plenty of employers here (e.g. me) who are looking to hire people.
- robinwarren 15y agoIncase anyone reading this isn't convinced that recruiters really are the biggest problem with jobs boards you could check out Tobin Harris' write up of his experiences here http://wip.engineroomapps.com/post/3927805265/hiring-without-agencies-lessons-learned-part-1 http://wip.engineroomapps.com/post/3927805265/hiring-without... For my part, recently I was in conversation with a friend who'd advertised a role themselves. They were getting calls from recruiters saying unless they took their candidates through them they would actively contact those candidates and tell them not to apply. They said they would tell the candidates that they'd already put them forward and not to bother applying. Jobs Boards without recruiters can I think benefit candidates and employers. The only people who wouldn't benefit would be the recruiters
- danohuiginn 15y ago
- kron4eg 15y ago"Have at least 200 karma or have been an HN member for more than 2 years" this is too restrictive.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoTo the extent that HN karma means anything, a 10 day-old account with 1 point just isn't a very strong signal. Hey, I have exactly 0 StackOverflow karma (and no account, but that's easily fixed). I'm hardly surprised that they don't roll out the red carpet for me.
- wccrawford 15y agoStackOverflow careers is current invite-only, with the caveat that if you have a nice GitHub account the company themselves will invite you. (I think there was another type of account that could get you access, but I didn't pay enough attention.) Perhaps a way around the restriction would be to adopt a similar system. People with 200 karma or 2 years would be automatically accepted, but others would need an invite from an existing member.
- kaffeinecoma 15y agoApparently if you ask them (and have decent credentials) you can get an invitation easily. I did.
- thomas11 15y agoI think if anything, it's not restrictive enough. The idea is that HN acts as a community filter for membership, and 200 is really not much for an active member of the community.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoOne simplification: try to parse e-mail addresses from the about: box, authenticate via e-mail. Obviously, ask for permission before sending e-mail - some people have employer-(provided/monitored) e-mail.
- arghnoname 15y agoIn addition to length or karma, you can look at length and karma. Lower length on HN means it takes a higher average karma to post, but not necessarily 200 karma (which I barely have, due to a low posting volume and not being very interesting, despite being here for a long time).
- stevelosh 15y ago> Would people use this? I definitely would have when my company was looking for a programmer a month or so ago, and would use it the next time we want to hire someone.
- vbrenny 15y agoAnd, additionally, if nobody uses it.. It's just the work of shutting it down. No big harm made.
- barrkel 15y agoDanger: could encourage (more) karma gaming on HN, if such a board actually worked.
- prodigal_erik 15y agoI comment pseudonymously so that I can speak my mind honestly. If this takes off, I would be somewhat tempted to create another account and write enough shallow, uncontroversial, professional, heavily self-censored comments to reach the threshold under my True Name.
- hr 15y agoSeems you really need better filtering tech to keep off the information that is offensive to you. Limiting the amount of information is good how?
- blumentopf 15y agoI'd welcome such a job board. And it would be wonderful if it won't be just for permanent jobs, but also for contractor jobs.
- filipcte 15y agoHN karma would be a great metric for vetting experience and track-record. It's one of the trickiest things when trying to hire above-average talent. May I recommend using jobberBase (http://www.jobberbase.com http://www.jobberbase.com) as a platform? Also open-source, with a great community around it. Disclaimer: I've built jobberBase, so I'm biased :).
- themal 15y agoMake sure that the name of the employer is a required field. There's so many job websites these days which are dominated by agency ads.
- gommm 15y agoI'd definitely use this...
- raarky 15y agoHow about some kind of "This is an agency!" button in case one somehow manages to get onto the system?
- adaml_623 15y agoMake sure the name of the employer AND the location of the job is a required field. Give it a try. Worse case scenario is loss of face.
- troels 15y agoWhen can you have it done by?
- alexsherrick 15y agoI've been hanging around the site for a long time, but I haven't been here for over two years. Is it really necessary to have that long of an account to stop spam? I believe 1 year should at least be fine.
- jgrahamc 15y agoSince there's enthusiasm for this I will set the site up and submit it here. Unless PG cries foul and says he doesn't like me hijacking the HN karma for this purpose. OK. I built it. Here's the announcement: http://blog.jgc.org/2011/06/usethesource-job-board-for-hackers.html http://blog.jgc.org/2011/06/usethesource-job-board-for-hacke...
- natural219 15y agoI don't meet your qualifications, and I'm already thinking to myself that I need to post/comment more. So here's a data point.
- jgrahamc 15y agoI decided to change it to over 1 year instead of 2.
- mrcharles 15y agoHave a field for telecommuting as well. I wouldn't mind switching in to web dev, but I don't want to leave Toronto to do it. Places that would accept telecommuting would make that easier.
- wyclif 15y agoYes, please. It would be much more useful that way.
- bherms 15y agoI'm planning on building the reverse soon. Hacker Resumes I guess. If you're looking for a job, you post info about yourself, location, links to all of your relevant info, and select from a few categories. Companies can then browse and see if anyone meets their needs.
- dgunn 15y agoNow that's an idea. Good job. (Not that the other one is bad. This is just my preference)
- bherms 15y agoI think it's a more efficient process for companies. Instead of getting 1000 resumes, of which only 100 may even be relevant, they can browse by specialty, experience, keywords, etc to filter through.
- noinput 15y agoaside from the fact most of us will need to have a resume again, +1 for this idea.
- kaffeinecoma 15y agoYou're aware that there's already careers.stackoverflow.com, right? That said, is anyone else disappointed by the lack of response there? I'm not actively looking, but in ~2 months on the site I've had "search hits: 8, employer views: 0". Kind of disappointing, considering all the hype.
- bherms 15y agoCareers.stackoverflow is a good option, but the HN one keeps it within the HN community, which may not be as large, but is more close knit (at least from my experience). In addition, a HN Resumes would, in my mind, be a much simpler and straight-forward interface.
- dabeeeenster 15y agoI'd definitely use this.
- snikolic 15y agoI'd use it.
- sciurus 15y agoI would find this useful. Having a HN member in good standing submit the job sends a positive signal about the position. (shameless plug: http://eupathdb.org/ http://eupathdb.org/ is hiring a front-end developer, see http://bit.ly/kYH9zp http://bit.ly/kYH9zp for more information)
- wenbert 15y agoThank you. I've had very good results from HN contacts. I can't wait for this.
- AlexBlom 15y agoI think this is a great idea, and would use it very actively. What would be good is to get a shared GDOC going so you can capture the e-mails and cities of those interested? E-mail to keep us all in the loop, and city to make local hiring easier?
- stevenj 15y agoDirect link to jgrahamc's job board: http://jobs.usethesource.com/ http://jobs.usethesource.com/
- ghotli 15y agoThe jobs threads are already incredibly active on the first of every month. If you want the community to get into this you might try to come up with a way to scrape that data. Additionally! If you want people to actually remember this thing exists it needs to show up on the front page from time to time. I'd get with whoever is handling the automatic submission of job threads via the whoishiring account to see if you can get the link to your site added into the description field of the monthly threads. http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=whoishiring http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=whoishiring http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=whoishiring http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=whoishiring