3 ms·
My experiences exactly, my ad experiences fit in to two categories “things i just purchased” and “terrifically bad suggestions”. A third category might be “cree
by colechristensen 6y ago
My experiences exactly, my ad experiences fit in to two categories “things i just purchased” and “terrifically bad suggestions”. A third category might be “creepy connections” where a random search leads to ads on vastly different platforms usually quite inappropriately.
- bigiain 6y agoAmazon are terrifically bad at the “things I have already purchased” advertising. They _know_ with 100% certainty that I bought a webcam 6 months back - because I bought it on Amazon. Yet they’re still sending me email and putting ads on webpages for webcams, including the exact model I bought from them... (I totally expect some shitty AdTech startup to start buying remarketing ads for NFTs any minute now. )
- jefftk 6y agoHave you considered that Amazon is very good at what they do, and that perhaps people who buy a webcam are much more likely than then general public to buy another one?
- sillydrivings 6y agoConsidering that the same thing happened to me when I last bought a movie on DVD from them and then got ads for that very same movie for weeks, no.
- someguyorother 6y agoYou'd be surprised how often the people who are supposed to be good at ads aren't. Organizational inefficiency explains a lot of it: https://thecorrespondent.com/100/the-new-dot-com-bubble-is-here-its-called-online-advertising/13228924500-22d5fd24 https://thecorrespondent.com/100/the-new-dot-com-bubble-is-h...
- jefftk 6y agoThat may happen in many companies, but I'd be very surprised if it happens with remarketing ads and Amazon? Performance-based advertising with solid experiments that appropriately consider both counterfactuals and long-term user value is one of their core strengths.
- bigiain 6y ago> Have you considered that Amazon is very good at what they do Cynical-me considers Amazon to be the least-worst of all the companies trying to do what they do. I'm sure their "re-advertise stuff people bought before" thing works great for some of what they sell - toilet paper or laundry detergent or cat food. So just like every "data driven" VC backed startup, they've "validated the business model" and are now pumping advertising dollars into "scaling" their proven toilet paper sales pipeline to webcams. They're probably busy running multivariate testing to find if the optimal repurchase advertising repeat rate for webcams is down near 4.3 weeks like laundry detergent, or way up at 9.1 weeks like toilet paper. 'cause the data doesn't lie, right? :sigh:
- Viliam1234 6y agoMaybe the victim in this case is not you, but the company paying for the ads. Think about it this way: You buy a webcam from some company X. The company X wants to sell more webcams, so they buy ads. Amazon shows those ads to you. At the end of the year, company X gets a report saying "we displayed your ads to bigiain, and bigiain bought your webcam" (the little detail that you bought the webcam before seeing the ads is not mentioned). Would this seem to the company X as money well spent?
- seoaeu 6y agoAre the "things I just purchased" suggestions actually bad though? I see people complain about them a lot, but I haven't seen anyone chime in with what the conversion rate is on them compared to other targeting strategies. Like I'd suspect that having already purchased an item is highly, highly correlated with purchasing it again. And that probably even applies to things that don't initially seem like you'd need more than one of.
- edoceo 6y agoWhen I have my ad-blocker off I see a lot of ads for Linode, AWS and DO. I already have a relationship with each of them. Amazon still keeps showing me faucet valves and a kitchen-sinks. (I did a replacement two years ago). And, every last ad for any/all PostgreSQL commercial add-on. Some (many) items don't fit the repeat pattern and I'm confounded how, with all the Ai/ML crap this isn't known yet. They (ad-sellers) would rather hustle the BS of "retargeting"
- vidarh 6y agoOr it fits better than you think, and/or the margins for certain types of products are high enough to justify bidding for ads even when they fit only a tiny proportion of the time. E.g. you may have a relationship with Linode, AWS and DO, but presumably all three would prefer you ditched one or two of the others for more spend with them. And you may have done a kitchen replacement two years ago, but how many percent need to do repairs or changes subsequently, or are unhappy about choices they've made, and end up spending enough on high margin additional products for years to come? That you've proven yourself to be willing to invest in improvements recently might well make you more profitable to advertise to even though you've already made the biggest investment. I'm sure many advertisers are bad at targeting, and so I'm sure some of these ads are metaphorically burning money. But I'm also sure - because I've seen that too - that sometimes seemingly totally counter-intuitive ads makes sense after all with access to the actual underlying numbers.
- cycomanic 6y agoMy impressions about ads is they are usually not interested in selling you what you actually need, but they try more to get you to feel like you should buy things you don't really need. I suspect it is because it's easier and much more profitable (we would spend less money if you only bought things we want need).