3 ms·
> I'm not making anything equivalent Ok you say that, but your question > Why is it okay to slaughter and eat a cow and not a dog or a whale or a cat? implie
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
> I'm not making anything equivalent
Ok you say that, but your question
> Why is it okay to slaughter and eat a cow and not a dog or a whale or a cat?
implies equivalence. Without that equivalence the answer is obvious: Because they are different. It's ok to treat different things differently.
But ok, so let's talk about equivalence. Obviously cows and whales are both mammals. Maybe that's why I should treat them the same.
So is it ok to eat non-mammals? Snakes and lizards and fish? Why? They're still animals.
So let's say it's not ok to eat animals. So we should eat plants.
Why is that ok? They're still alive. They still die when you harvest them.
Okay so it's not ok to kill and eat anything. So we starve.
Obviously this is silly and reductive and does not represent reality. We have to eat. May as well eat cow.
- seanwilson 6y ago> Why is that ok? They're still alive. They still die when you harvest them. Why not stop at killing things that have a nervous system that clearly react with pain? Even if you want to argue plants feel pain, eating plants only is causing the least pain because animal farming requires more plants to die.