5 ms·
FUD. That's the point of the decades long propaganda campaign by the energy companies. If they can't convince you outright they at least want to create the co
by guelo 15y ago
FUD. That's the point of the decades long propaganda campaign by the energy companies. If they can't convince you outright they at least want to create the confusion and doubt.
- bad_user 15y agoWorking surprisingly well too.
- oelewapperke 15y agoProblem is, of course, that there are serious amounts of lunacy on both sides. The recent tornadoes, for example, are NOT the result of global warming. Neither is Katrina or any other historical event. Unfortunately, it's very obvious that the truth does not lie "in the middle". Also what this article does is so patently stupid it strains credulity. Event A will affect 100 variables and, by itself, cause a temperature drop of 0.3 degrees. Event B will affect the SAME 100 variables and, by itself, cause a temperature increase of 2 degrees. So now let's ignore all those variables and say "that'll give 1.7 degrees". That's NOT how it works, you have to simulate the effects completely, and then make an entirely new prediction of the combined effects. And, frankly, given the success rate of IPCC predictions (they've been making them since 1990 you know) ... I don't know how any scientist can claim with a straight face their predictions are reasonable. (we're outside their 95% confidence interval for their predictions for 1990, 1995 and 2000, and we're very close to leaving the 95% interval for the 2005 report too, given 1 prediction per 5 years and 3 mistakes already ... how exactly is this "95%" thing reasonable ? Each of these reports gave predictions 100 years out, and none of their predictions have happened after a mere 10 years (BTW: in all cases so far, it's cooler than predicted. I'm not saying the climate hasn't warmed)
- Typhon 15y agoDoubt is a very good thing. It's propaganda versus propaganda now. I will never forgive whoever has made global warming a political issue, because it means debating rationally about it has become impossible. Climate is a very complicated thing, especially when studied on a planetary scale. It's a bunch of chaotic parameters, and any prediction about it is likely to be wrong, or imprecise. Much of science works that way, but problems arise when you need to make political decisions about such matters. You can't make large-scale decisions that will affect millions based on flimsy predictions that may turn out to be wrong.
- ugh 15y agoSo, how exactly couldn’t it be a political issue?
- Typhon 15y agoBy focusing public attention on something else. It's not as if we had a shortage of problems. Then, the matter of climate change could be settled in a scientific manner, as opposed to a religious debate involving legions of people who don't know what they're talking about. Obviously, i'm being unrealistic. Once it's become politicized, it's already too late.
- ugh 15y agoThing is, whether or not climate change is happening has policy implications. Just settling it was never gonna be enough.
- arethuza 15y agoDeciding whether or not there is climate change and what is causing it is a scientific question. What do to about it is a political decision.
- DougWebb 15y agoNo, deciding what to do about it is an engineering decision. Deciding to actually do what the engineers say is the best way to deal with the problem, based on the science, is the only political decision.
- ugh 15y agoEngineers can't do that. You have to give them a goal and then you have to decide whether you like their plan for achieving the goal. The political process becomes important before engineers spring into action.
- Tichy 15y ago
- randallsquared 15y agoExcept that the Fear part of Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt is the staple of the other side.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoSadly, on the subject of climate change the FUD goes both ways, and the end result is that science suffers while everyone else peddles their agendas.