3 ms·
> electrical engineers have schematics, SPICE netlists; and so on. How much "and so on", though? Schematics. SPICE. VHDL. Verilog. That's all I can think
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> electrical engineers have schematics, SPICE netlists; and so on.
How much "and so on", though? Schematics. SPICE. VHDL. Verilog. That's all I can think of off the top of my head, but I'm not an electrical engineer. There might be a few more - especially for subspecialties like, say, power engineers.
How many languages do software engineers commonly use? Maybe ten. (I will admit that the word "commonly" is doing a lot of work for me...)
And you could look at something like TypeScript as being a new API on JavaScript.
So I'm not sure that we're that far out of line with something like electrical engineering. We just have a really long tail of languages that relatively few people use. To me, it feels like those "don't count" in a way, but you could regard it as cheating to ignore them.
Note well: I am not at all saying that the languages we have are optimal for programming. I'm just saying that as a discipline, we mostly use a very few languages.
- kazinator 6y agoRight, no much "so on and on", and note that those EE languages we mention are actually computing tools. Another consideration I should have mentioned is compensation. Civil engineers get paid for instantiating a new bridge somewhere. There is no money in cranking out programming languages. It takes years of dedication to just make one good one.
- musicale 6y ago> SPICE. VHDL. Verilog. That's all I can think of off the top of my head, but I'm not an electrical engineer There are dozens of hardware description languages. In addition to Verilog and VHDL I've encountered SystemC and Bluespec as well as a number of less popular and academic languages (Lola, Esterel, even JavaScript-based HDLs...) (I've also encountered various lower-level languages, for schematics, netlists, or VLSI layout.) Languages enabling formal specification and verification seem particularly hot at the moment. Matlab/Octave and Scipy/numpy are certainly big in EE for signal processing and other applications. Obviously C-like languages and Python are used in many EE applications, as are GPU languages like CUDA and OpenCL.