3 ms·
How does this square with “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedo
by sokoloff 6y ago
How does this square with “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
I believe that political speech is the category of speech which demands the greatest amount of protection and freedom from government meddling, even (perhaps especially) political speech that I disagree with, find inconvenient, or even abhor.
Government overreach by actors that I’m politically aligned with is to be rejected just as much as by actors I’m not aligned with. Don’t think of all the great things a government controlled by “your side” can do with all this power. Think of all the terrible things the “other side” can do with this power when they’re in control.
- NeverFade 6y ago> How does this square with “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” The whole play here is that congress will not make a law to limit free speech. The tech giants will limit free speech on their own, out of fear that congress will make other laws, such as laws to hurt them and break them down. They're basically being extorted by congress into doing dirty work (limiting free speech) that congress is forbidden from doing by the constitution.
- Aerroon 6y agoIt turns out that the ability regulate interstate commerce in practice allows you to regulate everything else.
- mch82 6y agoI’m watching the hearing on C-SPAN. Congress is asking better questions. Congress allows the content can be posted. They’re asking why algorithms recommend the content to users. For example, at 1:14:11 Frank Pallone asks if Facebook is aware that 64% of people in extremist groups joined after Facebook recommended the groups, not because those people actively looked for the groups. Facebook recommending a group (to make money by increasing time on site) is a separate issue from Facebook allowing a group (free speech).
- sokoloff 6y agoI think 100% of the (tech, 3D printer, and dad jokes) Facebook groups I joined after they recommended them. If 36% went searching for these extremist groups, that seems likely way higher than the platform average to me, but in any case that comparison needs to be made I think for the datapoint to be meaningfully interpreted.
- compressedgas 6y agoIt's a question of liability. Are the platforms liable for the speech of their users or are only the users liable? If the platforms are liable for the speech of their users, then they must filter. If they filter, they might be liable. But if they do not filter, they might not be liable. I think that common carrier status means that a platform isn't liable if it doesn't filter.
- ThrustVectoring 6y agoCurrent US law is extremely clear about the third-party liability that various internet companies have due to user speech. It's limited by Section 230 to knowingly infringing copyright and conduct by the platform that rises to the level of criminal activity (of particular importance is distribution of child pornography). If someone defames you on Twitter or uses it to send you death threats, you cannot successfully sue Twitter, their hosting provider, or their ISP. The only thing Section 230 has to say about filtering is that you aren't allowed to sue websites over their moderation decisions. The protection of liability for third-party speech is in no way dependent on whether or not the platform does filtering.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoExactly. A: Company decides that it won't allow X on its own platform. B: Government requests company to not allow X on its platform. C: Government tells company to not allow X on its platform. D: Government forces company to not allow X on its platform. Here on HN, we've been having a long conversation about A, and the majority opinion is that it does not violate the First Amendment. D clearly violates it. C also does, at least in spirit, and the more so if there is an implied threat to move to D. B... it's pushing the line, if not more. So, was this B or C? Or C with the implied threat of D? Or C with the explicit threat of D?