3 ms·
Everything you pointed out, if those were used as grounds for dismissal, would be acceptable, and to be frank I could even get on board with. That's not why ev
by salawat 6y ago
Everything you pointed out, if those were used as grounds for dismissal, would be acceptable, and to be frank I could even get on board with.
That's not why everyone wants him gone right now, and whether the eventual outcome would be the same, reasons matter, and the precedents we as a civilization set through processes and outcomes we allow to be seen as a legitimate way to do things matters.
https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/ https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/
None of the issues brought up in connection with the controversy that came to a head with Minsky were grounded in truth, at all. The FSF would lose massive credibility by abandoning a visionary founder who did nothing wrong. For heaven sake, if you've already have a slam dunk case, you don't need to descend to the level of making up excuses or slandering someone to get them out. Speak up to authority, but be truthful, honest, and right. Don't wait until the backstabbing is good, and turn them into pincushions. Doing that taints the movement, because no one wants to work with a group of people who get rid of someone like that. It's cowardly, and wrong, in every way imaginable.
- geofft 6y agoI don't understand how that link you provide refutes any of the claims in the email. It seems to address other claims, made by other people. The email does not discuss Minsky or Stallman's comments about him at all. I think precedents matter, and being truthful, honest, and right is important. That's why I think that the GCC Steering Committee should evaluate this request on its own merits, and not by saying, well, some journalists wanted to cancel Stallman for other reasons, and they're wrong, so we will refuse any argument about Stallman. Each argument should stand or fall on its own.