4 ms·
> Even achieving just one hour of storage globally amounts to 2.5 TWh of storage. By comparison the entire world produces ~300 GWh worth of lithium ion battery
by nicoburns 6y ago
> Even achieving just one hour of storage globally amounts to 2.5 TWh of storage. By comparison the entire world produces ~300 GWh worth of lithium ion battery annually
... so if we could increase battery production by just 10x, then we could create an hours worth of storage every year. That seems... very doable.
- thiht 6y agoThat sounds extremely expensive and not very green.
- manfredo 6y agoAnd then we'd have to continue that production for two and a half decades to get to 1 day of storage. And we'd also have to drastically increase our battery recycling capacity to match (remember most lithium ion batteries last 1000-2000 cycles).
- jeffbee 6y agoNobody needs 1 full day of storage.
- ch4s3 6y agoOne could imagine a series of cloudy windless days in the northern latitudes during the winter. Perhaps a large enough gird solves that problem? I have no clue.
- lutorm 6y agoBut the key is that if you're averaging globally, the solar power probably doesn't change much. You'll need a way to transport the energy instead, obviously.
- pfdietz 6y agoOne would not use batteries for the "rare, but prolonged" storage use case. You'd want something with lower capital cost, even if it were much less efficient. For example: hydrogen burned in turbines.
- Manfredo_1 6y agoHydrogen storage remains in the prototyping phase. We have no significant amount of hydrogen grid storage. Like thermal batteries or synthetic methane, hydrogen represents a potential storage solution but not one that we know will scale and be effectively deployed at the scope required. If we actually deploy 50 GWh of hydrogen storage, and demonstrate that it can cheaply and reliability be built at scale then your point would be valid. But until then, hydrogen represents a theoretical solution not an actual solution.
- pfdietz 6y agoAll the components of hydrogen, with the possible exception of low cost electrolyzers, don't need to be prototyped. It's existing technology. It's not like (say) molten salt reactors, in which fundamental development remains to be done.
- Manfredo_1 6y agoRight, and what company can I call right now to install 50GWh of hydrogen storage? It's existing technology, but it's a novel application of that technology. We haven't used hydrogen electrolysis as a form of grid storage before. And we certainly haven't used it for grid storage at the Terawatt hour scale. And that the scale we'll need to make wind and solar viable. 1 TWh isn't even 30 minutes of global electricity consumption.
- pfdietz 6y ago50 GWh of hydrogen would fit in one salt cavern of the kind already made for natural gas. Any numbers of companies can solution mine those caverns for you; that technology is many decades old. I'd need more information about the rest of what you want, as that scales by power not by energy capacity.
- acdha 6y agoThat’s a problem if you’re an island isolated from everyone else, and you don’t have geothermal, hydroelectric, or nuclear options. The better question is how much capacity you’d need on a national grid to be able to handle large regional sags in production without endangering people. As we recently saw with Texas’ catastrophic fossil fuel production failures the big problem is not the source but poor management and not being able to get help from the neighbors.
- nicoburns 6y agoIf we had smart metering, then we could simply restrict consumption in these (presumably rare) circumstances.
- Manfredo_1 6y agoWe'd actually need 3 weeks of storage to migrate to a fully renewable grid: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/03/01/12-hours-energy-storage-80-percent-wind-solar/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/03/01/12-hours-energy-stora...
- Qwertious 6y agoFrom your own source: "The solar heavy network wouldn’t need energy storage with an HVDC network." So no, we wouldn't need that. HVDC would be far cheaper.
- Manfredo_1 6y agoA solar heavy network would still need 12 hours of storage to accommodate nighttime energy use. More actually, because of greater seasonal fluctuations further from the equator. All of the Americas experience night time simultaneously for at least 8 hours a day. Even if we ran HVDC lines to the Sahara, there's still a period of time where most sunlight is shining on the pacific ocean.
- Qwertious 6y agoYes, 100% solar makes no sense. Thankfully, we have other sources such as wind. Also, if you can run HVDC to the Sahara you could run it to hydro plants, so I don't think that's a good hypothetical. But mostly, talking about pure solar just makes no sense.