4 ms·
Exactly what I thought would happen. Not only was reinstalling Stallman going to alienate institutional supporters, it's also really a slap in the face of a lot
by Barrin92 6y ago
Exactly what I thought would happen. Not only was reinstalling Stallman going to alienate institutional supporters, it's also really a slap in the face of a lot of newer free software supporters, young women in particular given Stallman's past behaviour and comments.
Also very interesting to see the difference in commentary compared to the reddit admin fiasco.
- drenvuk 6y agoI don't think the leader of the FSF should be making as many public comments about unrelated matters as Stallman has so I don't think he should be reinstated, but I also find that many of his comments are wrongfully interpreted. Logically and administratively, if quite a few of those ideas were followed through with we'd be better off as a society. Have you read them? Every single one of them is freedom bent.
- ianmacd 6y agoWhy should "the leader of the FSF" not make "as many public comments about unrelated matters as Stallman"? This seems to suggest that a leadership role results or should result, ipso facto, in a reduction of its occupier's freedom of speech. I don't follow that rationale at all, which isn't to say that I don't acknowledge that such comments can and obviously do in some cases lead to public distraction from the actual work of said leader, shifting the focus to the leader's perceived identity and moral fortitude. That's a lamentable development to be sure, but to advocate abstention from public discourse as a precaution against the danger of becoming a distraction from the cause you advocate seems to be a clear case of blaming the victim. Stallman is not at fault here.
- drenvuk 6y agoWhether you follow the rationale doesn't matter at all. The moment you become a public figure that leads an organization people will take a microscope to your life, using anything they can find as substance for juicy stories or their own agenda. It's not just Stallman. Pick any political figure. With the power and trust comes a target on your back. This is self-evident if you've see the news at any point in time in your life. It sucks but it doesn't make it any less true.
- liaukovv 6y agoSo how many young women did they attract vs how many old men they have alienated? Any numbers?
- iujjkfjdkkdkf 6y agoI only have limited perspective, but the people I know who are really interested in free software (including most notably my girlfriend) are really not interested in the other aspects or RMS or anyone else's politics, in relation to FOSS. There is this perception that people are sitting around saying "oh, well I like free software, but thay movement is dominated my mysoginists or whatever, there's no place for me". I don't buy that. Positive contributors are drawn to FSF over free software advocacy. Other personal/ personality issues only matter to most people when they are made so distracting they can't be ignored, and that just breeds apathy. So tldr, I agree with you, this may be appeasing people who have just taken an interest to make trouble, and sponsors that dont want to get involved, but it is completely alienating people actually interested in free software.