5 ms·
Which part of the 'true openness' of Android killed Samsung's deal with Skyhook? No - that was great PR on behalf of Skyhook, but don't fall for it. Google had
by nl 15y ago
Which part of the 'true openness' of Android killed Samsung's deal with Skyhook?
No - that was great PR on behalf of Skyhook, but don't fall for it. Google had no problem with Samsung (or Motorola) shipping Skyhook. The problem was that Skyhook demanded exclusive access to the WiFi access point data (ie, if they shipped Skyhook they couldn't let Google get the same data).
Among those other issues was the provision limiting data collection to Skyhook. Motorola asked Skyhook to waive that restriction, so as to enable Motorola to comply with its obligations to Google with respect to GMS. Skyhook refused to do so, proposing instead that Motorola disable the data collection functions of GMS on its devices, which Skyhook contended would not affect performance of other functions of GMS. Motorola responded that it could not proceed in that manner without violating its obligations to Google and its carriers, and that it was
therefore absolved of its obligations under the Skyhook contract. [1]
To quote Wikipedia:
In December 2010 a judge denied Skyhook's motion for preliminary injunction, saying that Google had not closed off the possibility of accepting a revised version of Skyhook's XPS service, and that Motorola had terminated their contract with Skyhook because Skyhook wanted to disable Google's location data collection functions on Motorola's devices, which would have violated Motorola's obligations to Google and its carriers. [2]
[1] http://www.socialaw.com/slip.htm?cid=20416&sid=121 http://www.socialaw.com/slip.htm?cid=20416&sid=121
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system)#Licensing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system)#Lice...
- Steko 15y ago"Google had no problem with Samsung (or Motorola) shipping Skyhook." You can put as many footnotes as you like, no one will take you seriously if you make claims like this.
- nl 15y agono one will take you seriously if you make claims like this Why? Google has a huge problem with missing out on the location data (ie, Skyhook having an exclusive deal). But Google very plainly doesn't have a problem with other people getting that data as well. There are numerous apps in the Android Market that do similar things, and many manufactures ship apps that dial home with location data (eg, anything that includes ads).
- Steko 15y ago"Why?" Because of the numerous direct quotes from internal Google emails talking about what a disaster it would be and how they quickly sabotaged the skyhook deals with their compatibility club. It's impossible even on a cursory read of what happened to takeaway that Google didn't have a problem with handset makers shipping Skyhook.
- nl 15y agoRead those emails again. They talk about what a disaster it would be for Google to miss out on the data, not that it would be bad for Skyhook to get the data. If you have "numerous direct quotes" then please provide them. In their absence I'd direct you to the footnotes I provided earlier. (Also, I'd note that the quote compatibility club was from an email referring to shipping LogMeIn, not Skyhook, although Skyhook included in their case documents)
- Steko 15y agoQuotes aren't hard to find. "This feels like a disaster :(" "I'll setup sometime this week so we can figure out a good battle plan" "That would be awful for Google" "I cannot stress how important Google’s Wi-Fi location database is to our Android and mobile product strategy" "It's sad to see"
- nl 15y agoAll those support exactly what I'm saying: Google wanted to make sure their service was included! None support your claim that Google tried to stop Skyhook being shipped as well.
- Steko 15y agoGiven: (1) Skyhook wanted it's service to ship. (2) Samsung wanted Skyhook's service to ship. (3) Motorola wanted Skyhook's service to ship. According to you: (4) Google didn't care Observe: (5) Skyhook's service did NOT ship. It's pretty clear that (4) is the non sequitur. What mystical forces do you suggest stopped this from shipping if not Google?