3 ms·
While Safari seems to get better and better, it still lags behind Chrome and Firefox in a number of end-user usability factors that are much more subjective tha
by dangus 6y ago
While Safari seems to get better and better, it still lags behind Chrome and Firefox in a number of end-user usability factors that are much more subjective than "how much RAM I'm using."
For example, try going to compass.com and using embedded Street View in Safari. It's nearly unusable.
Sure, you might say Chrome is going to have a monopoly on "making things work nicely with Google Maps/Meet" but then you jump on Firefox and the experience is just fine. Safari's the only one with compatibility issues in my subjective experience.
Microsoft Teams also has missing web functionality specifically in Safari, functionality that works perfectly fine in Firefox and Chrome.
There are many more examples than just these two. Despite being an incredibly popular mobile browser, and being the default browser on macOS, I find that Safari is the only browser that I have to periodically switch away from temporarily in order to get some random website to work properly. If I'm doing critical work like taking an online exam I will always choose Chrome or Firefox because I know I can depend on it working and being properly tested.
At the end of the day, casual users aren't staring at Activity Monitor all day, and for them RAM is "free." I have a Mac with 8 GB of RAM and I've never noticed any slowdown or issue from using Chrome, Firefox, and/or Safari all simultaneously along with many other open apps. I don't have to care about what my OS does to manage memory because it's 2021, not 1995.
I think we all know, of course, that Chrome is Internet Explorer at this point. We are close to another monopoly situation that I'm not confident the US Government will properly address.
- myko 6y ago> I think we all know, of course, that Chrome is Internet Explorer at this point. Mobile Safari is extremely popular and seems closer to old IE
- moron4hire 6y agoIt's easy to be popular when the only platform you run on is popular and mandates that this be the only browser that can run on it. Oh, sure, you can get something called Firefox on iOS. But it's really just "crippled Safari", as 3rd party browser apps must use the system web view, which does not have feature parity with Safari.
- dangus 6y agoNot at all: https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/worldwide https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/world...
- kitsunesoba 6y agoIn terms of marketshare and power in determining web standards, Chromium and Google are much closer analogues of IE and Microsoft. Safari may lag in picking up some features but it's nowhere near as bad as the situation with the last few versions of IE.
- outoftheabyss 6y agoIt’s not so much memory management, it’s battery that is a significant benefactor when using safari in my experience; of course only relevant using MacBook on the go. I do find chrome more sluggish on my 2015 5k iMac as well
- dangus 6y agoI totally agree with you. Still, saving some battery to have busted websites is almost never a good trade-off. Safari is still my default browser. It has better password manager integration and a number of OS integration features that I prefer. But, like I said, I find myself having to switch to another browser for a number of common websites. Furthermore, on my M1 Macbook Air, battery life is quite literally an irrelevant concern. Not only is the battery life longer, but the difference in draining rate between light and heavy applications seems to be greatly reduced compared to Intel (by my subjective measurement). Of course, I can understand that not everyone owns this particular machine.