7 ms·
How much total throughput can your wi-fi router really provide?
- rektide 6y agoReally hoping Smallnetbuilder is back in the game, reviewing routers. Used to be an invaluable site but not a lot of updates these days. On another topic, pretty devestating that OpenWRT runs on only one of these routers, the slowest/oldest one, the Netgear Nighthawk X4S aka the R7800, which dates back to 2016.
- ethbr0 6y agoDoesn't OpenWRT have a similar problem to Coreboot? In that they need technical specifications and currently-closed source firmware, in a low-margin business, where providing those is last on most companies' priorities? Or at least, those are needed to enable the latest-and-greatest in a direct hardware path.
- zokier 6y agoI don't think the situation is as bad as coreboot: Both the vendor firmwares and OpenWRT are Linux based so there is already some base for compatibility. And OpenWRT is not fully objected to blobs in drivers, so they don't need necessarily go digging down every smallest detail. Finally e.g. Asus has been publishing their firmware "sources" (containing gazillion blobs) so you don't need to do full blackbox reverse-engineering to reuse stuff there. There is this whole asusmerlin project repackaging the Asus firmwares: https://github.com/RMerl/asuswrt-merlin.ng https://github.com/RMerl/asuswrt-merlin.ng Ultimately lot of the issues fall down on Broadcom and Qualcomm being what they are and not even trying to upstream their drivers and other bits. I don't know if we ever will see another wifi chipset that will have as good and long support as ath9k.
- ciceryadam 6y agoWhile it's not OpenWRT, but I'm running this on my RT-AC86U: https://www.asuswrt-merlin.net/ https://www.asuswrt-merlin.net/
- zokier 6y agoI wonder what it would take to get plain Debian to run on the device. OpenWRT made lot more sense when routers had like 8/16M of flash and not lot more RAM, but these big modern routers are far more powerful so bigger OS shouldn't be as much of a issue
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoIIRC, that specific line doesn't have OpenWRT for the same reason that proper Debian support is unlikely: important parts of the networking hardware are only supported by closed blobs, and I vaguely recall there even being redistribution limitations on those blobs, which is why merlin builds exist but not openwrt.
- rektide 6y agoI'd like an in the know response, but Broadcom-based systems (yes the Raspberry Pi cpu folk) have been utterly unusable by OpenWRT & other Linux users for almost half a decade. The original WRT54G, for which OpenWRT is named, shipped with a Broadcom brcm47xx chip[1]. But something changed in the last decade, and Broadcom has been unsupportable, unusable, & there is no community, no folks putting their own Linux onto Broadcom based systems for a long time now. I would love to know the specific details, to know what happened. But the status quo is that Broadcom is the worst villian, is unsupportable, that nothing they do is generally usable by hackers & Linux users, and that any router with a Broadcom cpu in it is utterly unusable. It's worth mentioning that the Broadcom wifi drivers on Linux have been a constant tussle & difficult. For the longest time the MacBook's worst area of support when running Linux was the wifi drivers, owing to Broadcom's dis-support. I hope some day Broadcom stops being such a dark side impossible company. But there've been no points of hope that I've seen in the last decade. It's just gotten worse. Maybe it's us, maybe we haven't tried hard enough to see what access we might be able to get, maybe Qualcomm has become the main OpenWRT, Debian, &c running chip because it's what folks knew worked, because the long history of Atheros (who Qualcomm bought) being moral & good folks, who understood the relevance & importance of support, and we just haven't tried hard enough to force access to Broadcom, and that's on us. But right now, the status quo is, Broadcom chips are all useless to the world, aside from whatever software comes on them, and whatever software & support you get out of the box. A lot of people are very sad about this, and I recommend also being sad about this. https://openwrt.org/toh/linksys/wrt54g https://openwrt.org/toh/linksys/wrt54g
- mfkp 6y agoI've found this site incredibly useful for router reviews lately (and much more trustworthy than all the SEO-optimized review websites): https://dongknows.com/ https://dongknows.com/
- sliken 6y agoI had a netgear R7000 or similar, OpenWRT was rather painful. Didn't support Ipv6, had to steal a few binaries from DDWRT, and it was pretty hacked up. Infrequent updates, lack of security patches, etc. I was much happier with the Ubiquiti stuff, ipv6 just worked, regular easy updates, and it's been solid.
- rektide 6y agoi have a small fleet of r7800s. they support ipv6. no binaries had to be stolen. nothing was "hacked up". it takes about ~20 minutes to check out the git repository, use "make menuconfig" to choose my board, and type "make". about three hours latter i have a very up to date distro. your mileage may vary. personally i'd rather be running Debian, and have never quite gotten the spare time to try getting Debian going on these systems (i would borrow the kernel & maybe some other packages from openwrt, maybe even kexec in to Debian from openwrt). but openwrt has been low muss low fuss for me since I installed it on a WRT54GS a decade & a half ago. there's certainly some initial uncomfortability learning uboot, understanding what to do. but i've never had to go to any special measures for things to be just working. did you report any of your issues? are there bug reports for anything you encountered? nothing in what you wrote up sounds right or good or like what i've experienced or would want to. i hope some of these problems got captured.
- sliken 6y agoCool, I think mine was a few generations/years before the r7800, glad to see it's improved. Don't remember if I opened a ticket or talked to one of the devs on a irc channel. The dhcpdv6 daemon or similar would accept an IP from comcast, but not a /64 delegation. With the new binary it worked fine. Ah, yeah, mine was the ac1900 chipset, the r7800 is the newer ac2600.
- ksec 6y ago>Really hoping Smallnetbuilder is back in the game Lack of Funding, Ads revenue and Interest. The owner has mentioned this multiple times.
- rasz 6y ago~$100 Xiaomi AX6000 does full 1600Mbit if you have fully capable client https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNIKJ4mGigI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNIKJ4mGigI but firmware setup is in Chinese, and most likely contains some mandatory backdoors.
- secfirstmd 6y agoYeah not like those US backdoors... https://www.engadget.com/2016-08-21-nsa-technique-for-cisco-spying.html https://www.engadget.com/2016-08-21-nsa-technique-for-cisco-...
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoI really wouldn't suggest cisco for home use, either, history of backdoors certainly being one of the reasons...
- Youden 6y ago> and most likely contains some mandatory backdoors. Is there any evidence behind this assertion or is it just the usual fearmongering and baseless speculation?
- 10000truths 6y agoPeople who make these claims rarely have the knowledge to verify them. Anyone who genuinely wants to evaluate the security of a router can always run a packet capture or do a firmware scan.
- maccam94 6y agoWhat's a firmware scan? I believe that most router OS images and driver blobs are encrypted these days.
- nerbert 6y agoA quick Google of "China cyber security law" should give you a hint.
- jeffbee 6y agoIt doesn't matter how fast any of these routers is. There's no way I'm buying any of them until they lose their buggy, vulnerable management endpoints and get automatic, managed firmware rollouts.
- bawana 6y agoubiquiti dream machine with a ap ac pro?
- dsr_ 6y agoRun Debian stable on your routers. Use APs as dumb APs.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoAre there truly dumb APs? Because I'm really not fond of having Debian in the network core but the actual APs running unpatched proprietary garbage firmware either (especially if that's the part handling wireless security).
- sliken 6y agoDunno, define "dumb". Ubiquiti APs run linux, you can get a shell, but generally the APs are pretty simple and managed by their management util, which you can run somewhere on your network. The APs don't control the router, don't write/change firewall rules, and generally just focus on reliably handling wifi duties. So you could build yourself a router, run OpenWRT, pfsense, or whatever floats your board to control which packets go where, and which ports are visible from where. The APs do not need access to the internet, and generally anything sensitive going over the network should be encrypted anyways. I'd consider a router I control the OS and configuration of with a ubiquiti AP (or 3) more secure than the usual router configured by some corporation or running a bunch of wifi binary blobs.
- comeonseriously 6y agoI won't buy them because they look stupid. There's absolutely no need for them to look like a star wars ship or a bear trap.
- nullc 6y agoDo you like bufferbloat? Fixating on throughput benchmarks is how you get bufferbloat.
- pitaj 6y agoI assume bufferbloat will affect your latency, right? Is there really a tradeoff between latency and throughput?
- amarshall 6y agoThe negative effect of bufferbloat is indeed increased latency. But bufferbloat is a specific scenario—latency may be low when throughput is low even if the network path is susceptible to bufferbloat.
- nullc 6y ago> Is there really a tradeoff between latency and throughput? Assuming that the path under test latency is small to begin with, increasing buffering from reasonable to large to absurd generally provides a tiny and rapidly diminishing throughput increase. Part of the reason bufferbloat exists is because of norms in equipment testing focusing on throughput (esp for single/few tcp streams) and drops while ignoring other effects.
- colordrops 6y agoYou can measure bufferbloat and adjust appropriately if your router supports it.
- ronnier 6y agoI've stopped buying consumer routers for my home and instead buy small dual gig network x86 boards and put OpenWRT on it. OpenWRT is super nice now. Clean simple UI. Does everything I need, is open source and I have access to the entire system. Extremely happy with it. I graph my data in/out with grafana. When a new IP or MAC shows up on my network I get a push notification on my phone (I wrote a small script to do this). Really great to have options to do what I want. Also it runs wireguard.
- sigjuice 6y agoWhich x86 boards would you recommend for this? Thanks!
- ronnier 6y agoThere's a ton of options. But I'm using this one ... https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B086MK4YB8 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B086MK4YB8 It also has a SIM slot so you can fallback to LTE if your main internet goes down. I should mention. This doesn't have wifi. I buy distinct access points that are POE powered. For those, i use the WAX-610.
- zokier 6y agoWifi is the Achilles heel here. For example as far as I can google, that device has quite old Intel Wifi chipset which means 802.11AC only and no AX, firmware blobs, and worst of all apparently no AP mode support on 5GHz(!!!??). So not the best choice as a (wireless) router. That being said, I don't know what Wifi chipset would be really good option right now.
- sliken 6y agoWould just handle routing and wifi separately. Ubiquiti has a wifi-6 AP for $99 (2x2) and a "LR" version with 4x4 for $179. Then you can add whatever router you want and not have to worry about what next years wifi standard is.
- throwawaysea 6y agoOut of curiosity does some company benchmark other types of commercial networking devices like this? Things like load balancers, DDoS protection, switches, etc.? How do businesses shop for such products without having a standard measure from an independent third party?
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> How do businesses shop for such products Businesses are more interested in reliability, security, price, details of the warranty, support contracts, and other details that don't show up in benchmarks. If performance is key, they buy samples and test in their workload. Or at the enterprise scale, they might get loaner units from their vendors to evaluate. Benchmarks rarely tell the full story for unique workloads.
- Jonnax 6y agoKinda feels like you copy and pasted Oracle's official justification for disallowing benchmarks of their database.
- westurner 6y agonetperf and iperf are utilities for measuring network throughput: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iperf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iperf It's possible to approximate the https://dslreports.com/speedtest https://dslreports.com/speedtest using the flent CLI or QT GUI (which calls e.g. fping and netperf) and isolate out ISP variance by running a netperf server on a decent router and/or a workstation with a sufficient NIC (at least 1Gbps). https://flent.org/tests.html https://flent.org/tests.html `dslreports_8dn`: https://github.com/tohojo/flent/blob/master/flent/tests/dslreports_8dn.conf https://github.com/tohojo/flent/blob/master/flent/tests/dslr... From https://flent.org/ https://flent.org/ : > RRUL: Create the standard graphic image used by the Bufferbloat project to show the down/upload speeds plus latency in three separate charts: > `flent rrul -p all_scaled -l 60 -H address-of-netserver -t text-to-be-included-in-plot -o filename.png` In 2021, most routers - even with OpenWRT and hardware-offloading - cannot actually push 1 Gigabit over wired Ethernet, though the port spec does say 1000 Mbps.
- kevindong 6y agoReminder to take a step back and evaluate what you actually *need*. In my experience, software engineers tend to go overkill and buy the $300-400 prosumer routers that doesn't actually give them any tangible benefits over a normal $50-100 router. I live in a shoebox NYC apartment so a potato can give me pretty good service. The potato I picked was the TP-Link Archer A7 for $52 (at the time). My internet speed is ~280/~280 Mbps and I have successfully attained ~440 Mbps transfers speeds between my local file server (hard-wired) and my Macbook (over wifi). So the router is not a bottleneck to the internet from a wifi device. At any given point in time, I have ~15 devices connected to my router and it handles it great. My router supports band steering (i.e. the router and wifi device somehow jointly decide whether the device should be on the 2.4 GHz or 5 GHz band) so I get both great coverage and the best possible speeds at any given location in my apartment. I don't see the need (for myself, your needs will vary) to upgrade to a more expensive router.
- gambiting 6y agoI used to do exactly this, had a very expensive Linksys router until I discovered that I get higher WiFi speeds with the ISP provided BT HomeHub2 and just switched the Linksys off. And the coverage is pretty great too for the total cost of zero.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoI've sold every ISP-provided TP-Link I've had. The cheap "normal" routers crash all the time. Their firmware quality is worse than abysmal. Also, does your shoebox apartment have reinforced concrete walls? That would make everything much more difficult.
- kjjjjjjjjjjjjjj 6y agowifi is shitty. If you need throughput and low latency, just use ethernet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- r1ch 6y agoI refuse to use anything that doesn't support OpenWRT these days. The stability of a modern kernel, drivers and usermode can't be beat. While ax support is still a ways away, many ac devices support OpenWRT. I have the $70 wAP AC access point from mikrotik giving me ~400mbps TCP throughput at 2x2, WPA3 and zero buffer bloat and a $50 hEX which does routing/firewall, wireguard, network adblock and encrypted DNS.
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoDoes wAP AC support OpenWRT?
- r1ch 6y agoYes, though there are two hardware revisions - the newer model (2020 onwards) has a completely different chipset and no support yet (see comments at https://openwrt.org/toh/hwdata/mikrotik/mikrotik_rbwapg-5hact2hnd_wap_ac https://openwrt.org/toh/hwdata/mikrotik/mikrotik_rbwapg-5hac...)
- rubatuga 6y agoThe MT7621 boards support OpenWRT, but IMO, they are a buggy mess requiring constant reboots, or freezes after long-hours of torrenting. Just because it runs OpenWRT, doesn't mean its stable. I'm testing out a WRT-1200AC, which has an ARM processor rivalling that of SBCs. I'll post about the long-term stability of the WRT-1200AC on my blog in a few months. You can find the WRT-1200AC for about $50 USD on ebay.
- r1ch 6y agoI generally try to avoid anything with a Mediatek or Broadcom wireless chipset, Atheros seems to be the more stable of the bunch. My OpenWRT experience hasn't been entirely flawless - the switch on the hEX kept crashing until I found a forum post that said flow control was buggy, turned it off and it's been good since.
- rubatuga 6y ago
- infogulch 6y agoI bought a MicroTik hap-ac3 router with RouterOS for $100 which I hope will arrive soon. I like how explicit and clear microtik is about their products, but this would be my first one. Anyone else use microtik or routeros before? https://mikrotik.com/product/hap_ac3 https://mikrotik.com/product/hap_ac3
- throwaway888abc 6y agoGood investment, rock solid stability and performance. Installed dozen over years and can say only positive things about. Also, very flexible with configuration. One headache less.
- sliken 6y agoMore so than Ubiquiti? I looked at both and ended up with an Edgerouter and AP. Generally I prefer to keep my wifi and routers separate.
- infogulch 6y agoYeah... I prefer to own my network equipment instead of it being leveraged as a tool to extract money from me. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26628198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26628198
- infogulch 6y agoUbuquiti just took another dive... I wouldn't touch it with a 10' pole now. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26638985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26638985 > Whistleblower: Ubiquiti Breach “Catastrophic” > Trust me, this whistle-blower "Adam" (I have a few suspicions of who it actually is), toned it down. > The reality is much much worse.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoI've got a hAP ac² and while it is a bit more involved to set up than your average consumer router, it also exposes a lot of advanced functionality that you can really get into. I'll be adding one or two APs and managing them with CAPsMAN when we move to a larger house. IMO it beats Ubiquiti's offerings on functionality, but is behind on polish.
- drewg123 6y agoHow about latency in the face of interference from other APs? I just went through a battle helping a friend who is a streamer & who lives in an urban setting with hundreds of ISP provided 2.4 and 5GHz APs visible from her apartment. She had horrible glitching issues when live-streaming which I guessed were due to latency spikes when other APs were talking on the same frequency. I tried to research what routers support DFS, and settled on a Netgear AC3200 which they claimed supported DFS. However, we could never get it to select a DFS channel, and there was no mention of DFS in the firmware. After a week of useless Netgear "support", I just gave her an old TP-Link 5Ghz router I had laying around. It was running dd-wrt (or openwrt, I can't recall), and had no problem selecting a DFS channel. Since then, her streams have been nearly perfect. I just wish DFS was a feature these reviews tested
- glogla 6y agoI heavily recommend for everyone who wants to make correct decisions about Wi-Fi hardware to read this page: https://www.duckware.com/tech/wifi-in-the-us.html https://www.duckware.com/tech/wifi-in-the-us.html The author visibly knows their stuff and goes into channels, ac, ax, 2x2, 4x4, MU-MIMO, beamforming, etc in great detail. But the summary of what I took from that is the times when consumer routers were bad are mostly over. Modern high performance Wi-Fi has a lot of radio magic, so your two-antenna laptop can talk to two antennas of router via two multipath-propagated spatial streams while the router uses its two more antennas to form directed beams and get more signal so more range and speed. All of that needs a lot of signal processing magic, and is heavily proprietary and patented, so at the moment it won't work well on non-blob firmware and drivers. And even small manufacturers have trouble here - in pure Wi-Fi performance, Mikrotik would be behind Asus or Netgear or something, even if it has more features and more professional interface. Of course, you only need to care about that if you need local-network performance or you internet connection speed approaches Wi-Fi speeds, otherwise it doesn't really matter.