3 ms·
Some quotes I liked, from the first 15 minutes: > I think Steve Jobs was ... kinda putting you on. https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/12265/what-does
by neilv 6y ago
Some quotes I liked, from the first 15 minutes:
> I think Steve Jobs was ... kinda putting you on.
https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/12265/what-does-putting-someone-on-mean https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/12265/what-does-...
> 'What kind of new products for Apple in the next year?' Well, I think, uh, I can't get too specific about that, because, uh, we're into the, uh, the secret mode.
> ...the other level is, applications notes, etc, that have detailed information, but it's not nicely polished. And I think that's the sort of information that a lot of the club members here would be interested in. ... And that's, generally, a little bit of it gets done in engineering, but we get into, uh, boundary disputes with publications department. And what gets done is generally obtainable, if you can get through to engineering and ask for it specifically.
> Well, since we are a company, uh, no one -- it used to be, uh, one person, y'know, was pretty much the entire company, but now, uh, in order to be successful, you have to have the cooperation of the entire company. It works. We've gotten to the stage that everything is working as a, y'know, kinda a unit. ... And so, generally, I am not-- I can't go make a decision, and unilaterally tick people off.
I also liked his general engineering candor, which was expected. What I didn't expect (not knowing much about him, except reputation as a brilliant engineer, and so possibly fitting an old-school super-nerdy stereotype) was evidence of social awareness, when he caught himself a few times in what he was about to say, or said something a certain way.
Steve Jobs led some great things, but I wonder how different computing and the world would be, had Woz led culture and product vision. Would products throughout the field emphasize making over passive consuming? Would they be more honest? Perhaps even leaning towards altruistic (in substance, not PR story)?
- sebmellen 6y agoWhenever I think about this dilemma, I come to the conclusion that Woz, great as he is, just couldn't do the culture and product vision side of things. No doubt, he's a genius, but he's also a little quirky. I don't know if he could herd people as effectively as Jobs could. I had the opportunity to very briefly meet him at a blockchain conference (of all things) in LA in 2016, and he didn't strike me as a guy who wants to take on all the clutter and bullshit of managing people. People are much messier than clean, well-engineered technology.
- neilv 6y agoA lot of our talk about leadership is about MBA-style, influencing by charisma, large ego, maybe wanting to be in power, etc. What about leading by fundamentally admirable example? Would the people who decide to follow/join end up influenced more by merit relative to those values, than by high school popularity contest? For pragmatics of this hypothetical, what if the imaginary Woz-leader had, e.g., a Chief of Staff, who was aligned with Woz being leader, and who made sure the necessary things Woz didn't want to do or wasn't good at, still happened?
- sebmellen 6y agoMaybe that Chief of Staff model would work. I don't know. But just a little feedback — real leaders are not high school popularity contest winners. They are just very effective at managing human and other capital. Think of someone like Jeff Bezos. I think the biggest issue with a tech person being in leadership is that it takes a lot of time to develop the real soft skills required for leadership. That doesn't mean becoming your caricature of an MBA-style leader. It means actually understanding how to talk to people and get them to perform and do what you need them to. You don't get that by being a large ego-ed braggart. Then, it of course takes a lot of time to develop technical skills. If you want to be both, you will have a much harder time reaching the apex of both skill levels, hence why tech/business co-founding teams are very common. That's not to say one person can't be good at both both — many are — but these people are much rarer and are unicorns of their own. Often, you have to have some natural talent for one of these skillsets, and then work hard to compensate for your lack of competency in the other domain.
- gilgoomesh 6y agoYou're writing like Jobs kept Woz out of the spotlight. 1. Woz didn't obviously try to be a leader. He got very rich at Apple then went back to college in 1981 and eventually left Apple to work in education and small ventures. 2. Steve Jobs himself was sidelined at Apple and ended up on the Mac after getting kicked out of the mainstream projects at the company and was fired in 1985. The sad story about early Apple is that their marketing, management and board didn't seem to understand product design or engineering at all and were downright poisonous to their best performing employees. Jobs, Woz, Bill Atkinson, Burrell Smith, Andy Hertzfeld, Susan Kare, Rod Holt were all gone by early 1986. Rod Holt described early Apple like this: "after working what seemed to be sixteen-hour days and seven day weeks, I was exiled by new management — the fourth member out of five of the original Apple team to be retired or pushed out".
- colejohnson66 6y agoThe idea/claim that Jobs forced Woz out of the spotlight is a common one. It’s based in the idea that Apple wouldn’t’ve become anything without Woz, but that’s equally true about Jobs. Woz was the brains, but Jobs was the vision and marketing; he knew what to build, how to convince people to build it, and how to make people want something they didn’t know they wanted.
- antattack 6y agoIt could be because Jobs did get a job at Atari pretending that Woze'es work was his (or at the least not correct Atari's assumption) Also, Jobs lied to Woz, pocketing most of the money he made from Woz work optimizing a circuit board.
- colejohnson66 6y agoJobs isn’t benevolent by any stretch of the imagination. He was an egotistical jerk quite often, but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t part of what built Apple at the beginning. Woz alone never would’ve gotten there alone.
- pjlegato 6y agoA Woz-led company culture would have made Apple into something like Arduino or the Raspberry Pi Foundation: a cool, well-designed niche product for technically minded people to tinker with. A beloved product, yes; but a tiny company with no substantial broad technological, cultural, or economic impact in society.