3 ms·

This is true if you expect Elon to care to register his handle on every NFT marketplace. Which may be true for him, but not the majority of people.

capableweb 6y ago
What does that have to do with anything? You wouldn't confirm if Elon on Marketplace #1 by checking his profiles on Marketplace #2 (neither of which you know is actually is Elon). You would check Marketplace #1 and #2 by going to some place where he is verified like Twitter.
- strogonoff 6y ago
  So somebody who isn’t verified on mainstream social media or generally hasn’t made themselves publicly available for a comment is a fair target then? Besides, where does the idea that NFT purchasers even care who listed the NFT? They bought and own the actual item (artwork, tweet, etc.), who sold it is secondary—just as Mona Lisa doesn’t suddenly become something different if sold by a thief.
  - capableweb 6y ago
    > So somebody who isn’t verified on mainstream social media or generally hasn’t made themselves publicly available for a comment is a fair target then? Fair target of what? If someone gains a reputation using a anonymous wallet and sell their NFTs via that wallet, then that wallet is the author people would follow, no mainstream social media needed. > Besides, where does the idea that NFT purchasers even care who listed the NFT? Because the value of the NFT is around the chain of ownership, not sure why it's so hard for people to wrap their head around this fact. No, Mona Lisa painted by Moron #1 won't be as popular as Mona Lisa painted by Leonardo da Vinci. One could say the only reason Mona Lisa is popular, is because it's made by Leonardo da Vinci, otherwise it would get lost in the river of other, better art made around the same time. People don't actually care about the bytes. They care about who published the bytes, and that they now can be written as the owner of those bytes. Sure, you can copy the bytes, but if the ledger doesn't change to reflect that you now "own" those bytes, it's not hitting the same feeling as the ownership via NFT gives.
    - strogonoff 6y ago
      How does it matter if you sell your art as NFT or I sell your art while pretending to be you? An original Mona Lisa sold by an art thief is still Mona Lisa and is as valuable as if it was sold by a gallery. Buying Elon’s tweet NFT from a rando pretending to be Elon still gets you Elon’s tweet. Blockchain doesn’t care. And if people don’t care about the bytes, then what’s the reason for buying NFTs? Illiquid currency one has trouble using anywhere else?

capableweb 6y ago

What does that have to do with anything? You wouldn't confirm if Elon on Marketplace #1 by checking his profiles on Marketplace #2 (neither of which you know is actually is Elon). You would check Marketplace #1 and #2 by going to some place where he is verified like Twitter.

strogonoff 6y ago
So somebody who isn’t verified on mainstream social media or generally hasn’t made themselves publicly available for a comment is a fair target then? Besides, where does the idea that NFT purchasers even care who listed the NFT? They bought and own the actual item (artwork, tweet, etc.), who sold it is secondary—just as Mona Lisa doesn’t suddenly become something different if sold by a thief.
- capableweb 6y ago
  > So somebody who isn’t verified on mainstream social media or generally hasn’t made themselves publicly available for a comment is a fair target then? Fair target of what? If someone gains a reputation using a anonymous wallet and sell their NFTs via that wallet, then that wallet is the author people would follow, no mainstream social media needed. > Besides, where does the idea that NFT purchasers even care who listed the NFT? Because the value of the NFT is around the chain of ownership, not sure why it's so hard for people to wrap their head around this fact. No, Mona Lisa painted by Moron #1 won't be as popular as Mona Lisa painted by Leonardo da Vinci. One could say the only reason Mona Lisa is popular, is because it's made by Leonardo da Vinci, otherwise it would get lost in the river of other, better art made around the same time. People don't actually care about the bytes. They care about who published the bytes, and that they now can be written as the owner of those bytes. Sure, you can copy the bytes, but if the ledger doesn't change to reflect that you now "own" those bytes, it's not hitting the same feeling as the ownership via NFT gives.
  - strogonoff 6y ago
    How does it matter if you sell your art as NFT or I sell your art while pretending to be you? An original Mona Lisa sold by an art thief is still Mona Lisa and is as valuable as if it was sold by a gallery. Buying Elon’s tweet NFT from a rando pretending to be Elon still gets you Elon’s tweet. Blockchain doesn’t care. And if people don’t care about the bytes, then what’s the reason for buying NFTs? Illiquid currency one has trouble using anywhere else?