4 ms·
Why not just emulate an older computer? Using old hardware like that will be slow and inconvenient.
by charcircuit 6y ago
Why not just emulate an older computer? Using old hardware like that will be slow and inconvenient.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoDepends a lot on the machine in question, but in many (if not most) cases emulators aren’t particularly accurate and can sometimes be missing major features. For example if you want to run classic PowerPC Mac games with 3D graphics, you’re going to need an actual old Mac because no emulators currently implement enough of a GPU to run them. Aside from that, with emulators you’re adding layers of indirection and modern technology with unavoidably higher overhead (like USB) that impact latency — even if emulated machines are faster in some ways they can be less responsive than actual hardware. The best of both worlds are hardware recreations of classic machines using modern technology, but these are exceptionally rare. It’s a shame because with how much everything has shrunk, it’d probably be possible to build a meta-retro-box about the size of a NUC that contained hardware for a bunch of different systems.
- ddingus 6y agoThere are various FPGA solutions out there now. I have run some on my DE2 FPGA. This can be sweet and can really deliver the experience and can even use original peripherals, input devices, displays. I am settling on one, maybe two retro hardware setups. That is all the time I have. If I shrink it down to one, it will be an Apple //e Platinum. It is my fave. For gaming and other experiences, the FPGA options are looking like where the retro action will be at for more people as hardware ages, gets rare, whatever.
- ddingus 6y agoWhy not indeed? For most development, emulation is great. That is what I do a lot of the time. Having my modern environment handy makes old school dev targets easy, fast and fun. Sometimes, it makes sense to get real i/o and interaction. Here are a few examples: * What are the performance differences between fast emulation modes, recently made CPU accelerator hardware, old accelerator hardware, and a stock machine? That varies a lot! And emulation is not necessarily accurate. In the case of recent hardware option cards, it is not accurate at all. There are times when it makes sense to test, or attempt something new, and doing it on the real machine is always valid. Emulation may or may not be, depending. * I am making some low latency controllers for younger ones, and me to be honest, to game on and experience history. Going down this road has been fun. I got a couple great CRTs, have made some gaming controller hardware, and my young ones notice! All sorts of questions, observations. Dark room, late night phosphor trails, just by way of one small, but fun thing. They loved gaming that way. Have asked a few times to do it again. Fine by me. * I want to program on a 65816, and that was an upgrade from back in the day I never did. My accelerator card could come with that CPU instead of a standard, 8 bit 6502 variant. Emulation may cover this case, bit it may not do that accurately given newish hardware options I have on the machine. * I do use the machine for the following: Writing. Old school, comfy keyboard, display helps me to focus and write a bit differently. This is straight up creative writing and it is fun. Electronics. Have always done this and will continue. A fused card amd ribbon cable makes learning and building fun. I can use the computer to generate inputs, display results, etc. I got started with embedded systems this way and love doing it. Have learned a ton on an Apple, sometimes Atari machines back in the day. Still am. Gaming, and for me that is Nox Archaist more than anything else. I don't have a ton of time, so I like to make it immersive and fun. First time I sat down in front of one of these machines, actually a Plus model, not a //e Platinum, is an experience I remember vividly. Just last weekend I did that again, and we have come a long way! That perspective is nice. Has value. I am happy it all can work still. Edit: Frankly, a real system on a quality CRT is a great experience. Software emulation does not really do that well. Hardware, FPGA can, and I bet it grows nicely over the next decade. Software emulation, again, is my goto for dev projects. I do more than software on my retro hardware, so I maintain good quality retro hardware, and that leads me to the last reason: Other people are making cool stuff! We all buy kit from each other and it is a lot of fun.
- woodrowbarlow 6y agothe "kit" business model as a side-gig is really attractive to me. hardware designers who create some neat cartridge or modchip, order a few thousand blank pcbs, and sell the blanks along with a link to order all the components from digikey. the overhead for this business model is very low; pcbs don't take much room to store and managing orders at that scale is relatively simple. best of all: due to economies of scale, you can open source your hardware design without making much of a dent in your sales. since you bulk-ordered the pcbs, you can sell them cheaper than it would cost someone to make their own from your schematics (and you still turn a profit). now if only i knew more about hardware design...
- ddingus 6y agoI have been learning. Have help. Mostly buying others kits, but have exchanged boards and collaborated a few times. That is another fun electronics / retro thing. It is cheap to get, say 10 of something. Mail 'em off to friends for group tinkering.
- charcircuit 6y agoIt also saves you thousands of dollars from having to get something certified in the US. A few years ago I wanted to develop a hardware product, but I gave up once I learned how expensive certification and licensing can be. If you want to sell a rasperry pi with an LED and resistors attached to one of the GPIO pins you are looking at 5 figures worth of costs just to be able to sell a single unit in just the US.
- anyfoo 6y agoIn the context of it being a hobby here, you can do it however you want, and there are a lot of different reasons using these old computers one way or another. Some like finding out every detail of the hardware, some enjoy the challenge of breaking its known constraints. Depending on the exact situation, an emulator might work or not. I'm currently repairing old HP calculators. All of those can be very accurately emulated even on my iPhone, but I did it for the challenge, for the learning experience, and really because I just like the feel of the keyboard and the unit itself--and the broken ones are much cheaper on eBay. In the cases where an actual need is to be fulfilled, e.g. for business reasons (it happens), if an emulator works it can easily be the best possible way. If hardware is involved (including old disks), again it might not.
- charcircuit 6y ago>If hardware is involved (including old disks), again it might not. Ideally this would be emulated too.
- anyfoo 6y agoMy point was if you need to read stuff from old disks. You might not need an old computer and the exact disk drive (especially nowadays), but you certainly will need a disk drive of some sort.
- phkahler 6y agoYou can't get lower key-to-screen latency than an 8-bit computer on a CRT. Well, most of them. My Interact draws characters pixel by pixel.
- ddingus 6y agoBitmap character displays were kind of neat back then. My Model 100 does the same.
- charcircuit 6y ago>You can't get lower key-to-screen latency than an 8-bit computer on a CRT. Why? My current monitor has a refresh rate of 144Hz and a response time of less than 1ms. This means that it will have lower latency than a CRT on average. I am sure you can produce a video signal on something other than an 8 bit computer.
- phkahler 6y agoBut there is a lot of software on your system. The only thing in your favor is the higher refresh rate. When the 8bit system gets a key press, it literally writes one byte to memory to put it on screen. A modern system will have to paint a glyph - which is super fast - but then may have to go through a compositor and possibly wait for V-sync. You're luck if the software stack doesnt introduce at least one frame of delay.
- ddingus 6y agoAnd that 8 bit computer could drive higher refresh rate devices and still be lower latency, or at the least, par. At this point, there are some really fun options for this kind of thing! This chip: https://www.parallax.com/propeller-2/ https://www.parallax.com/propeller-2/ is 32 bit, can run at a few hundred Mhz and has a very simple, retro feel, in that the 8 processors run wither either concurrently and independently, or can be used in parallel. The fun thing about all that is being able to build up fairly sophisticated applications or perform advanced control tasks without needing the complexity of a RTOS. In that low latency case, one core would be delivering a character or tile display, maybe with sprites, and once that is done, your programs can be simple, write that byte to screen type. Frame locked, low latency, single or partial buffered display schemes are all possible, even racing the beam style. Display support exists from old school monochrome 50 / 60hz composite through VGA and HDTV analog at 1080p, to reasonable HDMI. Racing the beam on an HDMI display is possible much like a CRT, depending on how the display buffers the bitstream. I like to treat these like new retro devices. Good fun and practical. (Have one device in the field using the simpler, original edition.)