3 ms·
>(If you did want to argue against diversity libertarianism, you'd want to show that relevant systems are more fragile than anti-fragile; giving people more opt
by Barrin92 6y ago
>(If you did want to argue against diversity libertarianism, you'd want to show that relevant systems are more fragile than anti-fragile; giving people more options will usually make them worse
No, the more fundamental problem with 'diversity libertarianism' is that diversity and libertarianism cannot exist together. Increasingly complex systems, such as human societies (but even non-human systems) require control and governance as they grow larger to institutionalize and manage knowledge that makes them function. Complex system produce hierarchies required to manage them.
The fact that our complex internet infrastructure is managed by large companies isn't some kind of random accident or failure of government or whatever, it's the natural result of trying to tame complexity. (the notion that making complicated things is 'hard' the article stumbles upon).
The only way to get, locally at least, the kind of system that libertarians like is by embedding it in a system of governance that actively displaces the natural state of affairs. This is why you can have, paradoxically, Shenzhen within communist China but not in Germany, or charter cities in the UAE but not in France. Western countries with their moderate and constrained ability to exercise power lack the authority to create radically ungoverned spaces.