3 ms·
People misunderstand Rand because a lot of her ideas are irreparably contradictory. I have found that her work has become a bit like the Bible: you can find a
by smt88 6y ago
People misunderstand Rand because a lot of her ideas are irreparably contradictory.
I have found that her work has become a bit like the Bible: you can find a way to justify a lot of what you want to believe, and then you can discard the rest. Most of the Rand-lovers I know vote for Republicans and some vote for Democrats. Some (or all) of those votes must conflict with Objectivism, since so many of the parties' policies are opposite.
> Instead, the utopia in the book is one in which people voluntarily associate to form a society.
This is why I believe that governments should obsessively do two things: A) protect the rights and opportunities of children, who can't enter a social contract; and B) pay the costs of someone exiting the social contract.
For example, I believe the US government should offer people the cost to travel to any other country once. They would revoke their citizenship and their right to live in the US permanently.
After that, we can more honestly say that citizens have entered into the social contract and may be held to it.
- dfgdghdf 6y ago> For example, I believe the US government should offer people the cost to travel to any other country once. Funny idea. An anarchist (left or right) would ask: why should I move? Why does the US government get priority here?
- smt88 6y agoI'm glad that the anarchist has the right to ask that. The answer would be this argument: 1. Land on Earth is finite 2. Most people want a social contract (trading freedoms, like stealing, for benefits, like personal property) 3. Social contracts do not work unless they are geographically bound (ex: traffic laws only succeed if they are enforced consistently across a geographic area) 4. Through no fault of their own, some people (including anarchists) will end up inside of a geographic area where a social contract is consistently enforced (e.g. a state) The anarchist must move not because is some cosmic or absolute justice at play, but rather because they are at the mercy of the people around them. If they choose to assert their rights to A) stay within that state and B) violate the social contract, the other citizens will impose consequences on them. Between you and me, though, I think most anarchists are just people who are able to ascribe the drawbacks of social contracts without being able to ascribe the benefits. They think that less government means similar comfort with more freedom, and we know from history (and currently examples in feudal places like Afghanistan) that that is untrue.