5 ms·
I've never really understood "Individualism." There don't seem to be any circumstances in which "Individualism" is superior to "Cooperation" or "Collectivism" (
by endisneigh 6y ago
I've never really understood "Individualism." There don't seem to be any circumstances in which "Individualism" is superior to "Cooperation" or "Collectivism" (and that in of itself I believe is a false dichotomy to begin with as there are situations in which individualism is necessary to maintain overall collectivism) unless you ignore the fact that the individual is benefiting from past "Collectivist" actions.
Rand's Objectivism is not mutually exclusive with Collectivist, nor is it always necessarily Individualist.
Personally I believe individuals are becoming more and more far removed from the benefits of "Collectivism" and therefore are wrongly believing their (in)abilities are a result of their actions solely. Your own actions, of course, have an effect on your life, but we don't live in a vacuum.
If we collectively pollute the planet and it turns out that pollution makes it harder for children to learn, is it the child's fault for not learning properly or our fault for creating such conditions? Of course, the answer is it's a little of both.
- EvilEy3 6y ago> unless you ignore the fact that the individual is benefiting from past "Collectivist" actions. This. Modern individual can use something built by a group of collectivists and advance alone.
- jd115 6y agoI'm the other way around. I've always found it very hard to convince myself of when and how exactly collectivism is better than individualism. To me, one person is infinitely powerful. Add more than one and limitations begin. By the time you get to the "masses" there's practically no power left and the ability to act productively is so watered down that nothing of unique value is ever achieved (only more of the same). This is not AT ALL to say I don't enjoy cooperation and working / playing together with other people with different viewpoints or alternative perspectives. That's one of the best parts of living on this planet. So I'm not saying there's no value in others, or even that I could exist without others. But I AM saying I only value others for their individualism.
- endisneigh 6y agoI assume you work for an organization (whether it's a company, or informal group). I also assume this group is more effective due to the fact that it's organized vs. all of you attempting the same things alone. With that said, I'm not really sure I understand your position. Could you elaborate? I especially don't understand the "add more than one and limitations begin." That can definitely be true, but is not inherently so.
- jhedwards 6y agoThere's a rather fun sort of paradox here. For example, I just finished reading a book on Maxwell and Faraday, and they were both ambitious individuals who pursued their own view of things with little regard for the consensus of their day. It was to some extent due to their radical individualism that they were so revolutionary. On the other hand, they were both built up by other people. They had their influences, their sponsors, their teachers and their friends. They lived in a society that put value on and supported individuals doing science. So I think I agree with you, but with the addition that there needs to be a group that nurtures individuals for them to be effective. This is, I believe, the reason there was no scientific revolution in China despite the high level of development there for so long: individual accomplishments were inevitably done in service to the emperor, so revolutionary changes were discouraged, even feared, in favor of technology to maintain the harmony of society.
- ceilingcorner 6y ago> There don't seem to be any circumstances in which "Individualism" is superior to "Cooperation" or "Collectivism The introduction of radical new ideas? Committees don't change the world, they maintain it.
- anemoiac 6y agoI’m not sure this is true. New ideas/movements/inventions frequently come from people working together.
- slibhb 6y agoExcessive collectivism leads to war, death, and genocide because all political groups must always be oriented against something. Excessive individualism leads to an unhappy, isolated, dilapidated society and ironically almost always presages excessive collectivism. This is just one more area where we need to search for the golden mean.
- endisneigh 6y agoWouldn't excessive collectivism be consensus?
- slibhb 6y agoSure but people don't agree about things so you necessarily have to kill, banish, or jail the people outside the consesnus.
- endisneigh 6y agoWhy do you have to kill or banish people who you disagree with? I don't understand your line of reasoning at all. At this moment the two of us apparently do not completely agree - must one of us be killed or banished? Obviously not.
- slibhb 6y agoWe aren't killing each other because we both believe in individualism. "You go your way and I'll go mine". It isn't any of my business what you think as long as it doesn't interfere with me. This is an idea invented rather recently by especially cultivated Brits. Look at the Uighurs and the Rohingya. That's what happens when a group exists outside some political consensus in the absence of individualism. History is chock full of wars and genocides that are incomprehensible to us because we believe in individualism and those people didn't. Why would the Catholic Church give a shit about the Cathars? It makes no sense to us, but they did, enough to kill as many Cathars as they could find.
- EthanHeilman 6y ago>There don't seem to be any circumstances in which "Individualism" is superior to "Cooperation" or "Collectivism" (and that in of itself I believe is a false dichotomy to begin with as there are situations in which individualism is necessary to maintain overall collectivism) unless you ignore the fact that the individual is benefiting from past "Collectivist" actions. It depends what you mean by Individualism. I think a good and often used definition of individualism is that individuals have inherent value and inherent rights. This notion seems like a deeply valuable part of modern ethics and has made our society stronger. Individualism is the basis for concepts like human rights. At least from my perspective so much of the battle between the conservatives and the progressives is that the conservatives take a traditionalist view that individuals must subsume their will and happiness to the expectations of society; Often the traditional expectations of society. Whereas progressives and the left argue that individuals have an inherent right to live their lives the way they want assuming they aren't hurting anyone else. For instance gay rights is fundamentally built on individualist values, traditional western society expects gay people to not express themselves, whereas an individualist would say gay people have an inherent right to express themselves and social expectation be damned.
- malandrew 6y agoThe definition of conservatism I like is that systems that produce good things are very hard to create and build and very easy to destroy. Conservatism is just wanted to protect things that work. Where things go off the rails is when conservatives don’t understand why the system works the way it does and confuses it to be all good because it produces good outcomes. Where opponents of conservatism (revolutionaries?) go off the rails is that they only see the bad in the current system and have failed to understand what the current system was optimized for doing well. If you don’t understand what an existing system does well, then you lack the qualifications to propose a new system since the new system won’t fix what is broken while simultaneously preserving what is working well. In either case, whether you are in favor of an existing system or opposed to it, you need to dig deep and reflect on why things are done the way they are because you may be throwing out a kernel of brilliant insight and not know it or you may be correct about thinking that you’re dealing with an onion in the varnish. https://wiki.c2.com/?OnionInTheVarnish https://wiki.c2.com/?OnionInTheVarnish https://wiki.c2.com/?OldRulesWithForgottenReasons https://wiki.c2.com/?OldRulesWithForgottenReasons