4 ms·
The law is not a formal system, it's a tool for humans to decide how to act. If those humans decide they want a tyranny, no amount of words on paper could ever
by lmm 6y ago
The law is not a formal system, it's a tool for humans to decide how to act. If those humans decide they want a tyranny, no amount of words on paper could ever stop them.
- eecc 6y agoAnother way around is to water down the parts that displease your interests, or choke them up with insane process without formally violating the constitutional letter. The Italian constitution is among the most robust and failsafe legal ground truths you can have, yet it’s been made sausages of since day-two
- monocasa 6y agoIt's a bit of both, depending on what those in power need it to be. I think Gödel's concern was for the people who might not agree with it installing a dictator, but go "well, it's legal and it's what the founding fathers wrote" and therefore go along with it.
- user-the-name 6y agoDictators, in general, don't come to power unless some fairly large fraction of people actually want them to.
- monocasa 6y agoI've always seen that they come into power with a surprisingly small amount of support.
- _nalply 6y agoIt's enough if the support has enough power to convince others to go along.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoI think there’s a lot of ret-reconning real history: after a fascististic government loses power (as they invariably do, due to their eventual inability to secure cooperation from the intelligentsia; their own in-fighting, and general incompetence) the people who did vote for them are likely to deny it - who would admit to voting for something universally reviled after-the-fact? That then leads to an impression amongst the public that said-party had far less popular support than they actually did.
- monocasa 6y agoYou can also look at the actual vote counts. The Nazis won about 30% of their last election before taking power. They were a minority part against the liberals. "I don't want the nazis to come into power, but I also don't want brownshirts to assault me and my family, and I'm pretty sure I'll be OK if I keep my head down" is an understandable sentiment, if a bit cowardly.
- skissane 6y agoThat 30% of vote – actually in the July 1932 election it was just over 37% – was not enough by itself for the Nazis to gain power. Hitler gained power because non-Nazi conservatives such as Hindenburg and Papen[0] installed him in power, because they thought they could control him, and because they viewed him as a lesser evil than the socialists and communists who were also jockeying for Chancellorship, and because they saw appointing Hitler as Chancellor as an end to the gridlock in the Reichstag – the result of the election was that Nazis were the largest party but did not hold a majority, but the next two biggest parties, the socialist SPD and the communist KPD, could not unite against them because the KPD was under instruction from Moscow not to cooperate with the SPD. Leading representatives of industry and finance also pressured Hindenburg to install Hitler, because they saw it as an end to the political chaos and also as a defence against the threat of the socialists and communists, who might harm those economic interests if they gained the Chancellorship. Although Hitler only had 37% of the popular vote, he also had substantial support from Germany's elites. He gained power because he convinced the people with the power to give it to him. Of course, after the war, many of those same elites tried to pretend that their decision to give Hitler power never happened, or that Hitler had somehow forced them into it. [0] Papen was not a Nazi at the time Hitler came to power. He naïvely thought he could control Hitler and the Nazis; after a while he learned that not only could he not control them, they could control him, but by then it was too late. And then he became a Nazi himself.
- karlicoss 6y agoYet we use it to reason about things, so formalizing and finding inconsistencies leaves less space for exploiting it. Also even though math is backed by a formal system in theory, in practice no one has time to completely verify mathematicians' work bottom-up from axioms (at least until we become better at proof assistants). Ultimately it comes down to intuition and trust, i.e. these people understand the proof, and I trust them, so I think the proposition holds. And similarly in principle a large group of people can decide that they don't trust the axioms (they are arbitrary in a sense, just like laws), yet it formal methods in math are still useful.
- agency 6y agoI am reminded of Matt Levine's column from the day after the 2016 election, concerning legal realism: > But in the back of my mind I thought about Llewellyn. I thought about the fact that those principles can't automatically enact themselves, that they only work if the human actors in the system choose to follow them and to demand that others follow them. They persist because the people constrained by them believe themselves to be constrained by them. The Constitution, separation of powers, religious liberty, freedom of the press, an independent judiciary, the rule of law, equality of all citizens: There is a complacent sense in America that these things are independent self-operative checks on power. But they aren't. They are checks on power only as far as they command the collective loyalty of those in power; they require a governing class that cares about law and government and American tradition, rather than personal power and revenge. Their magic is fragile, and can disappear if people who don't believe in it gain power. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2016-11-09/brambles-partners-and-options https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2016-11-09/brambl...
- lmm 6y agoI actually had that in mind when I wrote the comment :).