4 ms·
Just to play devil's advocate... Surely the company isn't obligated to provide free software to every reviewer, right? Why should they subsidize a review that
by eli 15y ago
Just to play devil's advocate...
Surely the company isn't obligated to provide free software to every reviewer, right? Why should they subsidize a review that they know will likely not benefit them?
And I have no data to back this up, but I bet really BAD reviews get more traffic than reviews that fairly discuss the pros and cons of a mediocre game. I think there's at least a temptation for less scrupulous reviewers to really slam mediocre or overhyped games more than is deserved.
- gamble 15y agoThere's no question that game reviewers can be cruel, but it tends to be limited to games that aren't produced by major publishers, because they can strike back by withholding review copies. Blackballing isn't about cost; (which is trivial) it's about early access to the game so that the review comes out immediately after the press embargo lifts. Gamers want to read reviews before the game hits shelves in the same way moviegoers want to see the reviews before heading out on Friday night. In exchange, game publishers get free publicity. It should be a symbiotic relationship, but the publisher has more power than the reviewers, and in my experience the bias is almost always toward over-kind reviews.
- balac 15y agoTo back you up, I never read game reviews and am not a serious gamer, but I had read the ars duke review.
- scott_s 15y agoPublishers don't always distribute review copies ahead of release. That, however, is usually a bad sign.