11 ms·
Gödel's Loophole
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoThere is no need for a loop hole. A president can do plenty of illegal things without consequences already. Incrementally do it while the public becomes numb to it, or worse, while vocal supporters becomes more nad more entitles, and you get to a dictatorship.
- IsopropylMalbec 6y agoThe Wikipedia article about it mentions using Article V against itself, slowly erroding it and the Constitution. That doesn't seem like the loophole Godel might be concerned about. if he did find something more concerning then given his skills this looks like nearly perfect security by obscurity.
- jonathanstrange 6y agoI agree with that. If a logician like Gödel talked about an "inner contradiction", then I'm inclined to believe he really thought he had spotted a contradiction, not just some way of slowly eroding an article.
- Blammar 6y agoI might have heard that in Godel's library there was a book with the note: "I have a truly marvelous proof that the U.S. Constitution is unstable, but the margin of this book is too small to write it out." More seriously, this is actually a bit reminiscent of Fermat's famous comment. I suppose when the lawbots become operational in a few years, we'll get a full logical analysis of the Constitution and find the loophole(s).
- eecc 6y agoUhm but wouldn’t that be a halting problem?
- jimmyed 6y agoHow is it the halting problem?
- bregma 6y agoHow is constitutional law subject to Goedel's Incompleteness Theorem? Everything is computer science, or at least linearly transformable into computer science.
- setr 6y agohalting problem doesn't say you can't prove a program halts; it says you can't write a program to prove every program halts (or doesn't), because you can construct pathological programs to intentionally foil it. you can certainly prove some programs halt, or don't. int main(){ return 0; } int main(){ while(true){} } and presumably, the constitution has not been written in such a way that it cannot be proven halt-able, one way or the other. In which case, it's finite, and all paths can be evaluated
- FrozenVoid 6y agoGodel's loophole is technicality of minor importance if its entirely confined to the constitution. The real loophole likely relates to presidential powers in relation to constitution itself: the expansion of executive in 20th century and executive orders that have not been found contradicting the law, might allow a precedent to create an "emergency powers" system to bypass constitution itself and rule by decree('executive orders').
- matthewfelgate 6y agoWhat if the loophole is bigger and allows a individual congressperson to make a law or something?
- lupire 6y agoThe Constitution is already a pile of incoherent contradictions. There's no way a computer program could formally analyze it.
- lmm 6y agoThe law is not a formal system, it's a tool for humans to decide how to act. If those humans decide they want a tyranny, no amount of words on paper could ever stop them.
- eecc 6y agoAnother way around is to water down the parts that displease your interests, or choke them up with insane process without formally violating the constitutional letter. The Italian constitution is among the most robust and failsafe legal ground truths you can have, yet it’s been made sausages of since day-two
- monocasa 6y agoIt's a bit of both, depending on what those in power need it to be. I think Gödel's concern was for the people who might not agree with it installing a dictator, but go "well, it's legal and it's what the founding fathers wrote" and therefore go along with it.
- user-the-name 6y agoDictators, in general, don't come to power unless some fairly large fraction of people actually want them to.
- monocasa 6y agoI've always seen that they come into power with a surprisingly small amount of support.
- _nalply 6y agoIt's enough if the support has enough power to convince others to go along.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoI think there’s a lot of ret-reconning real history: after a fascististic government loses power (as they invariably do, due to their eventual inability to secure cooperation from the intelligentsia; their own in-fighting, and general incompetence) the people who did vote for them are likely to deny it - who would admit to voting for something universally reviled after-the-fact? That then leads to an impression amongst the public that said-party had far less popular support than they actually did.
- jl6 6y agoSpoiler: the article consistently mentions that we don’t know what the loophole is, so the article is incomplete.
- toxik 6y agoIs that a theorem?
- matthewfelgate 6y agoEvery article is incomplete or has contradictions.
- sancho_panza 6y agoOne postulation asserts it has to do with self-reference, which is fundamentally incomplete.
- rtpg 6y agoThis is the prototypical "wow the nerd tried to solve law and lawyering". Yes, the constitution can be ammended to be less democratic. It can also be entirely ignored by everyone, and things can also happen in ways that go against its text, with judges looking the other way! People are not magically bound by words on a piece of paper, so if you end up being able to go through the (extremely arduous! Moreso than many countries) ammendment process successfully you probably have enough popular support to do whatever you would want in any universe, even with a stricter requirement. It's embarassing that this anecdote is given almost any weight. It's absolutely the most navel-gazing useless analysis. It does help to serve as an excellent counter-argument to "philosopher kings", though....
- admissionsguy 6y ago> Yes, the constitution can be ammended to be less democratic. It can also be entirely ignored by everyone, and things can also happen in ways that go against its text, with judges looking the other way! Or the words of the constitution can be reinterpreted to mean something entirely different than what they originally meant.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoIt’s baffling that some people believe banning something by law prevents it from happening.
- raverbashing 6y agoWell it doesn't, but there are other people "supposed" to prevent it. But yes, law people sometimes forget that it's all words on paper.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoSupposed indeed. But in the US, the top tier of said people is also heavily political and partisan. Anyway, the rule of law quickly becomes irrelevant when something takes over by force. Currently Myanmar is controlled by a military coup, for example, and there was an attempted coup by civilians in the US not too long ago (while the legal and military branches of it stood by and did nothing)
- tempaccount99 6y agoI suspect such loopholes exist in other constitutions, constitutions like source codes have influenced other constitutions. Most recent small example in this area : Government of India used article 370 to ammend article 367 which again affected article 370 to change status of Jammu and Kashmir.
- jimmyed 6y agoNo tempaccount99, that would be a regular amendment. Not a fascist dictatorship-ish "loophole"
- aaron695 6y agoNo it's not a regular amendment, as tempaccount99 explained. More here - https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/kashmir-why-amendments-to-article-370-may-not-withstand-judicial-scrutiny-119080600557_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/kas...
- jimmyed 6y ago> Gödel responded "Oh, yes, I can prove it," but the judge declined to pursue the matter. Such a mundane judge. It's as if someone says to a physicist "I have the General Unified Theory" and they decide to not listen to it.
- alimw 6y agoIf a truly ingenious method exists, probably best that nobody knows about it! Thankfully the current crop of would-be American dictators doesn't look smart enough to figure one out for themselves. (Brute force remains an option.)
- guerrilla 6y ago> It's as if someone says to a physicist "I have the General Unified Theory" and they decide to not listen to it. That happens all the time. The probably judge ignored Gödel for the same reason physcists ignore cranks.
- seanhunter 6y agoRealistically this is more akin to a physicist hearing from a non-physicist they have a design for a perpetual motion machine and declining to pursue it. Gödel was clearly a giant in his field but here he is completely outside of the rubric of things he was familiar with. Specifically the constitution describes a political system not a logical one and while logic is important for the law, it does not describe anything like a formal system of logic (in the mathematical sense). Judges are also incredibly busy and they probably had a huge caseload to deal with and little time right then for a detailed constitutional debate.
- saberdancer 6y agoThis is why there are checks and balances. The laws and constitutions are not rules in a game that can be exploited arbitrarily. There is an intention behind them and law is and should be interpreted in that way. If this loophole exists it probably goes against the intention of the lawmakers and would be struck down by supreme court.
- monocasa 6y agoThere's some thought that it's around presidential pardons, and it's not clear the supreme court would strike down nearly any use of them or allow the legislature to do so short of an amendment.
- eek04_ 6y ago> If this loophole exists it probably goes against the intention of the lawmakers and would be struck down by supreme court. It's Common law not French/European law. The intent of the lawmakers is, in common law, more or less completely assumed to be present in the text of the law. French/European courts looks to the context the law was made in and other documents produced; common law judges mostly don't (but do look much more to precedent.) And there is of course the problem of judges in the US being fairly strongly partisan politicised (since all power in the US is partisan politicised), so the interpretation will depend on which party has lately stuffed the supreme court.
- user-the-name 6y ago> This is why there are checks and balances. Should be, yes. But "are"? How sure are you about that, given the last four years?
- panax 6y agoA despot may also pack the Supreme Court to change the rules, although the existing Supreme Court may prevent the court from being packed. I am curious what would happen if all the members of the existing Supreme Court were to suffer an unfortunate accident in this situation. edit: Of course you still need Congress to approve the nominees.
- 6y ago
- wkyle 6y agoThere seems to be a lot of dismissal in this thread about the consequences of a Constitutionally-legal road to dictatorship. The historical precedent to this concern is the Nazification of Germany. After Hitler was appointed chancellor, the Enabling Act[1] was passed as an amendment to the constitution. This gave Hitler the power to pass unconstitutional laws without parliamentary or presidential approval. I think the possibility of iterative erosion of Article V such that the the entrenched clause that protects the composition of the Senate from change without unanimity can be removed is very comparable. This is concerning in an age where a once-majority party has been largely supportive of a figure who's displayed dictatorial tendencies. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enabling_Act_of_1933 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enabling_Act_of_1933
- DavidPiper 6y agoI love that Gödel's Loophole is itself incomplete. Very fitting.
- lurkmurk 6y agoSo what was Austria's loophole?
- foobar02 6y agoIt's without a doubt amending Article V with Article V; I don't really understand why it's thought of as some mysterious loophole lost to time. Not everything a smart man figures out has to be particularly complex.
- DebtDeflation 6y agoIt almost certainly involves Article V, but likely not in the trivial "amend Article V to change the 2/3 supermajority to propose an amendment to a simple majority and eliminate the requirement for 3/4 of states to ratify" sense. That would never actually be ratified as states would be loathe to give up their power. My guess is it would first involve the creation of a considerable number of new states under Article IV and then proceed to amend Article V as above by enlisting the newly created states. The part I can't quite explain is how those states get created without dividing an existing state which requires the consent of that state's legislature. Edit: Really, the more that I think about it, the ability of Congress to create new states by simple legislative action (so long as the territory does not come from existing states) IS almost certainly the loophole. Every new state, no matter how small, gets 1 Congressman and 2 Senators. Create enough, and you control both houses of Congress. Since the EC vote is determined by number of Congressmen + the number of Senators by state, you'd also control the Presidency. Since the number of SCOTUS justices can be changed by simple legislation, you'd now control all 3 branches of government. At that point, using Article V to amend Article V just becomes the final icing on the cake. Edit 2: DC is not a state, and so would not be subject to Article IV constraints on making new states from existing ones. Article I Section 8 gives Congress complete jurisdiction over DC. Reserve a portion of DC as the US Capital, divide the remainder into 150 new states. I think I just found Gödel's Loophole. Or maybe I'm just "a nerd trying to solve law" as someone else posted, that's entirely possible.
- rezonant 6y agoThis seems like much more of a loophole than just modifying Article V -- You can modify any part of the constitution via amendment, it's like root access. But your scenario here wouldn't require the "actual" states to sign off or would at least override them. Nice post!
- drawkbox 6y agoThe Constitution and Amendments though typically only work when they expand rights/freedoms rather than contract rights/freedoms. A good example is the 18th Amendment [1] which was drug prohibition of alcohol in 1920 which was reversed with the 21st Amendment [2] in 1933. The addition took away rights/freedoms and it led to a bad phase in America as well as created mafias and underground black markets that sapped money from the regular markets. Interestingly, the country went through the Great Depression towards the end of that timeline. James Madison, who wrote the Constitution, most of the Federalist Papers AND the Bill of Rights, wrote the Bill of Rights specifically for individual freedoms so that the states would not want to rewrite the Constitution in another convention. Any addition to the Constitution that doesn't add more freedoms, rights or expand the power of the people and their pursuit of "Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness" as stated in the Declaration of Independence, will be misguided and discarded. Using amendments to strip away the main body of the Constitution, unless for more rights/freedoms, would be an incorrect use of the design goals. Almost immediately after beginning to meet in 1789, the first Congress, led by James Madison, began to consider amendments to the Constitution proposed by the state ratifying conventions. George Washington and Madison had personally pledged to consider amendments because they realized that some amendments would be necessary to reduce pressure for a second constitutional convention that might drastically alter and weaken the new federal government. Fastening on Anti-Federalist criticisms that the Constitution lacked a clear articulation of guaranteed rights, Madison proposed amendments that emphasized the rights of individuals rather than the rights of states, an ingenious move that led to cries that these amendments—now known as the "Bill of Rights"—were a mere diversion. "I will now add what I do not like. First the omission of a bill of rights..." Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, December 20, 1787 [3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eighteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eighteenth_Amendment_to_the_Un... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-first_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-first_Amendment_to_the_... [3] https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/creating-the-united-states/demand-for-a-bill-of-rights.html https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/creating-the-united-states/dema...
- raverbashing 6y agoAgree. As the fundamental law of a country, what makes sense to have there is: - Basic freedoms/rights - The government limits/boundaries (legislative and in regards to citizens) - How the government should work (on a very high level) The rest is better to have as laws/treaties. (Though to be fair sometimes it would be helpful to be more specific, still laws always move much slower than the times and technological changes might be difficult to consider using a past lens) The US constitution is to be fair one of the most concise ones. As you correctly point out, prohibition is something that shouldn't have been even there
- yottalove 6y agoIncorporate core rights of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights into the body of the Constitution ensuring, as Article 30, that any attempt to weaken or remove any of these rights automatically invalidates the entire Constitution. This makes it too legislatively burdensome to weaken and would unequivocally signal a coup is taking place.
- Vecr 6y agoI'm pretty sure the current constitution is in direct conflict with at least some of the UN's stuff, so I doubt that would work at all.
- k_sze 6y agoWhat if Gödel never actually found a loophole but simply intentionally left behind a cryptic puzzle, with the influence of his celebrity friends, so that future generations will keep scrutinizing the constitution, watching it for dangerous changes?
- tom_mellior 6y agoEven simpler: What if Gödel never actually found a loophole? The only source we have is Morgenstern recounting an anecdote more than twenty years later. He may well have misremembered/misunderstood/taken out of context/embellished some remark that Gödel made. It makes for a good anecdote, but that doesn't make it true.
- Parzival99 6y agoJill Lepore discussed this in her New Yorker article when discussing Linda Colley's new book, The Gun, the Ship & the Pen. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/03/29/when-constitutions-took-over-the-world https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/03/29/when-constitut...
- bregma 6y agoReading all the comments here, my reaction is 'Whoosh!". Perhaps it is possible to use Cantor diagonalization to demonstrate there are forms of humour that are not accessible to everyone?
- exo-pla-net 6y agoI think that the majority of people chuckled and moved on. The people who were, for whatever odd reason, perturbed or galvanized by the amusing little article compose the group that self-selected to comment. I think this is a peril of reading the comment section before checking out links. If it's not worth talking about, you'll only find unhinged or pedantic conversations about it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mik09 6y agoknew of this a long time ago, it's godel, what do you expect?
- motohagiography 6y agoLaw isn't code, and nor is a constitution, but it appears the point of the second amendment was to be a backstop against most of the things that could go wrong in such pernicious applications of the law, where if the people can revolt within the confines of the rules, you don't have to throw out the constitution and everything it built. If he found a rule that could be used to overwrite every other rule, there is the option to use popular revolt against the party who was abusing it. As they say, it's a republic, if you can keep it.
- dw-im-here 6y agoSurely if all the legal luminaries of HN banded together we could rewrite the constitution in a statically strong typed language and formal verify it.
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoConsidering HN, it would probably be written in Rust.
- thedudeabides5 6y agoConsidering HN, it would probably be written by GPT-3.
- Craighead 6y agoConsidering HN, it would probably wouldn't happen
- lajarre 6y agoDown for it. With catala-lang.org for example.
- peter_d_sherman 6y ago>"Gödel's Loophole is an "inner contradiction" in the Constitution of the United States which Austrian-German-American logician, mathematician, and analytic philosopher Kurt Gödel claimed to have discovered in 1947." [...] >"Since the exact nature of Gödel's Loophole has never been published, what it is, precisely, is not known." Gödel was a brilliant, brilliant Mathematician. There is no doubt, no question about that! In fact, he's one of my personal "Mathematical Heros". In the same league as Ramanujan, Gauss, Euler, Newton, etc. But, while he was all of this, he was also "rank amateur" in terms of finding contradictions in what is commonly called "The Law" (even though this article might have you believe otherwise). Wow, he found one contradiction in the Law! And of course, they don't tell you what it was exactly, leaving you guessing, leaving you wanting to know more -- a common trick used by Hollywood (and book authors) for getting and keeping the audience's attention! One has only to study the Law, or what is commonly called "The Law" -- for a few years, with the mind of a Logician or Computer Programmer -- to discover many, and I mean, many, contradictions... Here's a "fun one" to "whet your whistle": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Protection_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Protection_Clause >"The Equal Protection Clause is part of the first section of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The clause, which took effect in 1868, provides "nor shall any State ... deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws". It mandates that individuals in similar situations be treated equally by the law.[1][2][3] [...] >"Text The Equal Protection Clause is located at the end of Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment: All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. Now, compare this equal protection of the laws, with the extremely unequal way that Covid-19 lockdown laws were implemented, State to State, in the United States: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_lockdowns#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_lockdowns#United_Stat... >"Stay-at-home orders in the United States have come from several states and a large number of local jurisdictions, sometimes leading to conflicts between different levels of government and a patchwork of inconsistent dates and rules.[610][611][612]" Sometimes leading to conflicts, Wikipedia? ? Try more like ALL OF THE TIME! That is all of them -- are in conflict, contradiction, with the Equal Protection clause of the Constitution. You see, for a State's Laws to be valid under the Equal Protection clause of the Constitution, it's an all-or-nothing deal. That's because all Laws are like half-filled glasses of water; that is, they have a filled part, and they have an unfilled part. If half of a Law is what protects people, it's like the filled part of the glass of water. The other half of a Law is what encroaches on other people's freedoms and liberties; it's like the unfilled part of the glass of water. If the Laws which protect people (and simultaneously encroach on other peoples freedoms and liberties) are not exactly equal, in each and every State, all of the time, then this would not be unlike each State having its own glass of water -- that was filled to a different level -- than each of the other States... In other words, no longer are individuals in similar situations -- treated equally by the law. The Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution -- has been violated -- by these asymmetric, contradictory "Laws". They are therefore, at least according to the Constitution, at least according to the Equal Protection Clause -- fully and thoroughly Unconstitutional (or contradictory, phrased another way) -- yet that hasn't seemed to have been much of an impediment to the groups and parties that implemented them, nor does it seem to be an aspect of things that was discussed or talked about much in the mass media... But, long story short -- there are many contradictions in Law -- if one but studies the subject matter with the mind of a Mathematician, Logician, or Computer Programmer...
- lurquer 6y agoThe Constitution fails to describe how States are to conduct their elections for federal officers. A group of states, for instance, could do something silly like hold an ‘election’ via mail-in ballots with no verification of citizenship, residency, etc. So, you could have a corrupt party in charge of a handful of states take over the Presidency, Senate, and House. And, from that point, it’s a trivial matter to pass legislation ensuring that party’s perpetual power, whether it be through grants of amnesty to millions of non-citizens, or federal laws requiring a method of voting that favors the party, etc, etc. But, these things could never actually happen, of course.