7 ms·
I want a Linux phone. I like open source too, but I'm not serious about it, I want to be able to fix things or file an issue on GitHub or whatever if necessary
by OJFord 6y ago
I want a Linux phone.
I like open source too, but I'm not serious about it, I want to be able to fix things or file an issue on GitHub or whatever if necessary, but I don't have the energy to worry about proprietary blobs.
Having control of my phone and its configuration like I do my Linux desktop is what I want, but I'm slightly resigned to perhaps not getting it because of app support (I tried Anbox on my desktop, it was buggy and slow, with a fraction of the RAM I dread to imagine) - so I've been thinking about and occasionally working on a Terraform provider for Android instead. So far I'm using it to install all apps, no Play Store at all; I'd like to have it handle settings too.
So yes, it is Linux more than OSS that appeals to me here, because it's control more than openness that interests me in it. (I suppose some wouldn't see a distinction, and that's partly why it is more important to others.)
- rahimnathwani 6y agoWould you be happy with a FreeBSD phone?
- Shared404 6y agoOnly if I can install a program without needing a developer account with the manufacturer.
- speed_spread 6y agoNo! On the other hand, a TempleOS phone would make my day, and the CIA's.
- NexRebular 6y agoA lot happier than with a linux phone. Would love to have an illumos phone too, but won't get my hopes up for that happening any time soon...
- Koliakis 6y agoIs somebody working on one?
- rahimnathwani 6y agoI have no idea. I was asking because I wanted to understand better the position of the person to whom I replied. They said they wanted Linux specifically, and not just open source. I didn't understand why it's so important for it to be Linux, as opposed to any other operating system that's as hackable/customizable. So I wanted to know if I had missed something.
- Shared404 6y ago> I didn't understand why it's so important for it to be Linux, as opposed to any other operating system that's as hackable/customizable. I should apologize for my response then. I'd thought you were alluding to iOS, and thought that it was strange to bring that up when discussing configurable OS's.
- Koliakis 6y agoI don't think it being Linux is too important for people. If somebody made a working FreeBSD for a phone and there was official support for that device, then people wouldn't be all "Well, it's not Linux". I don't think I've seen any interest from BSD maintainers to bring any form of it to phones though. As it is now, the PinePhone is officially supported by Manjaro and that makes it the most obvious option. Also, all attempts thus far to bring open source to mobile has been some form of Linux, so it's natural that when people think "open source phone", it's probably going to be using Linux. PinePhone itself already has 18-ish different distros, including ports of Debian and Ubuntu, so it's certainly well on its way.
- macdice 6y agoYes, I would like a FreeBSD-powered phone that can run Android or iOS consumer apps totally sealed inside virtual machines.
- rahimnathwani 6y agoOne VM per app would need a lot of RAM. Maybe one VM for Linux/Android, and one for iOS, would be a decent compromise. We'd still 'waste' some RAM, but isolation between different Android apps could be handled by cgroups/namespaces.
- esrauch 6y agoHe said Android or iOS. It seems like massive overkill to have a phone that can run both. Even running Android apps well is a pretty tall order, running iOS apps natively on your own open source phone seems like a pipedream. It took even Google a long time and a lot of investment to get Android apps to work reasonably well on ChromeOS.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoIf you're talking FreeBSD you would use jails instead which eliminate a lot of the doubled up resources. It's a lot more like docker containers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- macdice 6y agoTrue. The question is whether the Linux emulation can be good enough to satisfy Android. There are lots of funny quirks ... I wish something like CloudAPI/Capsicum would take off to be more secure, while also being an open platform, instead of Linux ubiquity rendering standards irrelevant.
- Apocryphon 6y agoTechnically iOS is the closest thing to a *BSD-powered phone, because of the Darwin lineage.
- Apocryphon 6y agoA BeOS phone would be pretty sweet.
- IgorPartola 6y agoI think you have it completely backwards. You want a phone that runs a FOSS operating system. It doesn’t matter to you that it is Linux or a BSD or some other open source kernel. Android is a Linux phone but it’s decidedly not open.
- whateveracct 6y agoNah I want a NixOS phone
- tadfisher 6y agohttps://mobile.nixos.org/ https://mobile.nixos.org/
- OJFord 6y agoNo, it's not particularly important to me that the OS is FOSS (it's a bonus I appreciate, but what I dislike about my work Mac is that it's hard to configure and changes between versions and bundles crapware, etc., not that it's not FOSS). Another Unix would be ok as long as it's not hidden away under a forced UI, with some things unconfigurable, required, etc. But ultimately I want to share dotfiles between my desktop and phone (sure I might have to accept some amount of conditional guards..) - and that pretty much means Linux and ideally Arch. But only because that's what I happen to use on non-phones.