3 ms·
This argument is flawed in several ways: 1. Repetitive tasks get progressively faster with the keyboard as the motion gets smoother as your practise it. 2. He a
by andybak 15y ago
This argument is flawed in several ways:
1. Repetitive tasks get progressively faster with the keyboard as the motion gets smoother as your practise it.
2. He allows two-handed using editing Ctrl+X/C/V as a special case but there are other similar situations.
I'd like to see the exact methodology. 2 seconds to decide which key press to use sounds fishy to me.
- raganwald 15y agoIsn't your first point also true of mouse movements under certain circumstances? I am specifically thinking of the Apple style of fixing the menu at the top of the screen given the display resolutions at the time, and of "pie menus" on today's hardware: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu A friend works on high-end image editing software (Maya). Their research is that pie menus are faster than keyboard commands and both Apple and Windows style menus because the user is learning write flicking gestures and their hand is already on the mouse for drawing activities.
- eropple 15y ago> 2. He allows two-handed using editing Ctrl+X/C/V as a special case but there are other similar situations. Like "all of them." The only command shortcuts I actually use one hand for are Ctrl-(Z|X|C|V), Alt-Tab, and Ctrl-Tab - everything else, I hold Ctrl with one hand and press the key with the other hand. It feels more natural that way.