2 ms·
If anything the last two decades have taught me to question putting all the eggs in the raw democracy basket. The baseline contributer doesn't invest a lot of t
by asdff 6y ago
If anything the last two decades have taught me to question putting all the eggs in the raw democracy basket. The baseline contributer doesn't invest a lot of thinking into the often quite significant stakes at hand. The opportunist knows this, and exploits these populations for their vote. In the end the system is still controlled by a small influential few, but now their actions are sanctified by being supported by the democratic vote and it is now much more difficult to get rid of these opportunists when so many blindly support them against their own interests.
Using an internet example, if we didn't like the bent of the admin team of a site today, we find another website maintained by someone with shared interests. If we remove top down control and enable the masses to control a site like reddit, then you really are handing the keys directly to the opportunists, and every site will have the same voices eventually churn to the top.
Organic democratic voices simply don't exist on this for profit commercialized internet we've constructed over the last two decades. SEO wins, virality wins, pandering to xenophobic fears and conspiracy theories wins over data and facts. We are a far cry from the learned men of Athens discussing the affairs of the city from the Pnyx; democracy today is like the dirty rowdy bar by the city gate where people are complaining about immigrants speaking foreign languages coming to the docks.
- slibhb 6y agoI am contrasting juries and representative systems (republican ideas) with "raw democracy," which is fundamentally mob rule. We haven't always viewed the Athenians as "learned men". Polybius judged Athens negatively: he saw the Athenians as an example of mob rule. We also have ancient commentators like the Old Oligarch, who was critical of Athenian democracy (though he saw its utility). Of course the measures I mentioned to curtail mob rule are not completely effective. What I'm saying is, we seem to be in the process of reinventing the wheel and so let's take look at our existing vehicles, which function fairly well.