That's a good hypothesis re: the MCU firmware on the NAND. If it's true that all NAND needs to be periodically refreshed, then it could be as simple as losing p

That's a good hypothesis re: the MCU firmware on the NAND. If it's true that all NAND needs to be periodically refreshed, then it could be as simple as losing power while one of the firmware sectors is getting refreshed. That seems like an obscure enough scenario that there's dragons lurking around it. I like to imagine in my head that the MCU in an SD card can detect its voltage dropping quickly enough to get into a safe state most of the time. With all the recommended capacitance around the socket, it might actually have a few milliseconds to work with after external power loss. When you pull the card out of a socket, though, the MCU stops working before it has time to do anything about it.