3 ms·
If you wouldn't come back with a gun yourself to resolve the issue, it's a dick move to call someone else (a cop) to come over with a gun. If you're making pho
by sneak 6y ago
If you wouldn't come back with a gun yourself to resolve the issue, it's a dick move to call someone else (a cop) to come over with a gun.
If you're making phone calls for armed response because someone is playing music, the problem might be with you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CDSlice 6y agoI'm pretty sure they called the cops on their neighbor because they were getting assaulted ("having to block punches"), not because of the music.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt depends on the context. If someone lives in multi unit housing and repeatedly blasts music or does it at odd hours in the middle of the night, I would assume the probability of them being anti social and not conforming to expected behavior to be very high, such that I might feel more comfortable with police dealing with them. If it’s a once in a while thing where they’re celebrating or whatnot and it sounds like they’re unintentionally disturbing others, then it’s probably worth talking to them.
- chao- 6y agoSaying "be prepared to pull a gun, or don't ask your neighbor for anything" seems like a false dichotomy. Isn't that the very reason societies develop laws and governments? To not have people using violence to get their way? Instead agree to follow a code, and standards, and to not adjudicate transgressions of those codes with individual-on-individual violence?
- sneak 6y agoI didn't say anything about pulling a gun, just that if you aren't willing to arm yourself and re-engage, it is a dick move to call someone else armed to come over and do it for you. It has nothing to do with violence. The correct move is obviously to not re-engage, personally or by proxy. > Isn't that the very reason societies develop laws and governments? To not have people using violence to get their way? Quite the opposite. Laws are enforced exclusively via threat of violence, and the only thing that distinguishes the government from any other leadership organization is a claim to legitimate use of violence.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoThis is one of the most insane comments I've seen on hacker news. Police are there to enforce the law. The only reason they have guns is to defend themselves or the lives of others. If I ask you to turn down your music at night, and you refuse, it's not legal for me to enforce noise ordinances myself, so I call the people who do such things for a living.
- sneak 6y ago> Police are there to enforce the law. When I see statements like this I wonder if we experienced the same 2020.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoI still haven't seen what your suggested course of action is? Alright, let's say I have a neighbor playing loud music at 2am. I walk down, ask nicely if they'd turn it down. They ignore me. What then? What am I supposed to do from that point?
- sneak 6y agoYou seem to feel your options are escalate to violence (or the implied threat of same) by calling the cops, or just deal with the loud music. I personally am with Asimov: violence is the last refuge of the incompetent. It has little to do with whether you employ the violence/threat yourself, or call a man with a gun over to do it for you. The correct course of action in almost all circumstances is "do nothing". There are some good reasons to escalate a situation. I'm not of the belief that a noise disturbance is one of them.
- abduhl 6y agoYou start by saying "you feel your options are limited to X or Y" and then go on to say "X is the last refuge of the incompetent, do nothing" implying there is some other option besides Y when you do nothing? So your real response is: when confronted with someone who refuses to engage with you on the level of a decent human being, just take it. This doesn't seem like the way civilization works to me. You've edited in a nice little tidbit about "well sometimes you've got to escalate" but failed to provide where that delineation is for you. Loud music isn't it. What about gunshots? What about children screaming loudly? What about someone breaking in to your neighbor's? When is it OK to escalate?