3 ms·
> In this particular instance I find myself asking why it matters that the Weaver residents were originally not from Austin. If you’re born in Chicago, shouldn’
by mindslight 6y ago
> In this particular instance I find myself asking why it matters that the Weaver residents were originally not from Austin. If you’re born in Chicago, shouldn’t you still have the same rights as someone who was born in Austin?
Not necessarily. It's not about where you're born, but about whether you've been somewhere long enough to be part of its community. You have the same natural rights, obviously. But not the same standing in the community, input into cultural norms, or right to legal enforcement contrary to those cultural norms.
Going with the principle of live and let live, when you visit or move to some place with a different culture, it's on you to accept that culture. Showing up, planting yourself, and then demanding everyone else conform to your own culture will rightly create pushback.
This is a conservative stance, and it can be taken to the extreme to justify a whole bunch of horrible shit as you mention ("newcomers are of a different nationality, or race than current residents"), which I am certainly not condoning. But the same goes for every heuristic turned into a political axiom - the tamer form is still valid.
(edit: I changed "fit in" to "accept that culture", because the former bites off too much, and can too easily turn into an indictment of a person who others consider different even though they aren't acting to cause a problem)
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Going with the principle of live and let live, when you visit or move to some place with a different culture, it's on you to fit in. Live and let live works for small things where there is no material effect on others, such as your spouse’s ethnicity or gender. For matters affecting others, such as noise, pollution, etc. live and let live is not applicable. For all of those matters, the ultimate force is might makes right, but some places have democracy that allows votes to serve as proxy for might, or frequently money serves as proxy for might.
- mindslight 6y agoThings like noise are exactly what I was referencing by the local culture. My point in invoking live and let live is that things like noise do not matter when you are far enough away. So different communities can exist with different norms regarding noise (or yard maintenance, farm smells, etc), and that is a good thing. When someone used to one type of community moves into a different type, it falls to the person moving to accept the culture of where they're moving to. So for example it's unreasonable for someone who gets up early for work to move into a building full of college students, and then complain about the late night parties. The alternative is to insist that there is one "right" culture, presumably yours, and to demand that everyone else conform to it. This is wrong.