You're not wrong.. but honestly I don't understand what people expect when _browsing the internet_. If "all my household devices come from the same IP" is a pri

You're not wrong.. but honestly I don't understand what people expect when _browsing the internet_. If "all my household devices come from the same IP" is a privacy requirement for you then you're always going to need NAT. And the advantage of your scenario disappears if any of those devices actually communicate with google's servers because then you can profile the requests, look at user agent, probably get different tokens, etc. Your nit seems so marginal to me I don't understand how championing this type of privacy paranoia is beneficial for internet technology. If you're worried about google seeing your traffic the answer is simple: don't send it to them.