5 ms·
You wrote: "If you have some hydrogen atoms, and then you do something to them, and suddenly you have some helium atoms, that's fusion." And that's just wrong
by pfdietz 6y ago
You wrote:
"If you have some hydrogen atoms, and then you do something to them, and suddenly you have some helium atoms, that's fusion."
And that's just wrong. There's a famous case from early on in the history of nuclear physics, where someone passed current through hydrogen gas and then found helium, and thought it was fusion. But what it was was helium diffusing out of the glass of the apparatus.
This should be the default assumption, because supposed cold fusion making 4He is a triple miracle: first that DD fusion occurs at all, then that it makes 4He, and then that it doesn't go through the normal channels (actually a quadruple miracle, since also that the 4He fusion doesn't dump its energy in very energetic gamma photons.)
- at_a_remove 6y agoRead the original paragraph I wrote. C'mon.